THE HALF DECENT FOOTBALL MAGAZINE

8 July ~ A World Cup perhaps more notable for its drama than its quality will reach its conclusion on Sunday. England’s participation was more footnote than headline and in this context the news that Fabio Capello will see out the remainder of his contract will raise little comment in other countries. More to the point, the retention of the manager is of little long-term significance for any improvement in the team’s performance in future World Cups. Given Capello’s track record, he may well be able to tease out an improved performance during qualification for the European Championship from a squad remodelled to replace some of the tarnished generation.

It’s easy to see why the suits at the FA want to focus on Capello’s future: it creates the illusion that they are part of the solution, rather than a key part of the problem. The coming months will doubtless bring other distractions, with revelations of disharmony in the England camp, the impact of boredom, in-fighting between factions and arguments over tactics or formations. Whatever this tells us about the recent round of poor performances, it will tell us nothing about what needs to be done in the future.

The core of the problem is around youth development and coaching. Although the FA now claim that coaches are being trained in the same numbers as they are in other European countries, that still leaves England playing catch-up. Training more coaches is only part of the story and the progress made in Germany, since their poor showing in the 2000 European Championship, is widely promoted as a model for creating a strong infrastructure for youth development.

More striking is the strength of the relationship between the governing body, the DFB, and the Bundesliga, with a mutual interest in the development of the national team. But just as important is the recognition that youth development is crucially a matter of co-operation rather than competition.

Routine turf wars between the FA, the Premier League and the Football League about player development show how far England has to travel. The creation of the National Football Centre will help coach and manager training, but a more positive role in the development of young playing talent was a victim of FA and League in-fighting. The FA’s dysfunctional decision making, where the Leagues can block any change they dislike, leaves resolution of these problems as far away as ever. Clearly, conflict of interest means something different within football.

Add to this the parlous state of the FA’s finances, with the major skills development programme dependent on commercial sponsorship from Tesco, and it is difficult to be confident about the future. A structure like Germany’s costs big money. The real sadness here is that the FA’s Trevor Brooking and the Premier League’s head of youth development, Ged Roddy, seem to have much in common when it comes to understanding what needs to be done.

Perhaps just as important is the worry that not everybody in English football recognises the need to change. There is plenty of evidence for this: the blithe assumption that, despite a lacklustre opening group game, England would have too much for Algeria and Slovenia and, apparently, Germany; the constant assertions of the world standing of players in the squad seemed impervious to the evidence. The apparent reluctance of some Premier League clubs to release players for the forthcoming European Under-19 Championship simply adds to the view that English football, despite evidence from as far back as defeat to the Hungarians in 1953, remains astonishingly parochial.

But never mind – Fabio is staying, television income continues to rise and the Premier League reminds us that it is the "best league in the world". What is there to worry about? Brian Simpson

Comments (5)
Comment by Lincoln 2010-07-08 11:24:49

It is popular to complain about the youth in all walks of life, especially football when we do badly in a tournament. I would agree were it not for our runner up place in the Under 21s and Under 19s, and of course our win this year in the Under 17s. The bigger thing is the lack of trying out these youngsters. Joe Hart was not meant to play according the all knowing media because he didn't have the experience.

Comment by gtheo 2010-07-08 11:27:55

Spot on with that assessment. I really can't believe that we are being so short-sighted in this country still. There needs to be some kind of drastic overhaul with immediate effect and I would hope that Capello has the strength of character to omit some of the 'big names' against Hungary and play youth. This may not result in instant success but might just pay dividends in the future.
I'm a teacher by trade. My school ran a football tournament on Monday in which most of the school took part. It was depressing to see PE teachers shouting out to kids to 'play it long' over and over. If we're getting that imbedded into them at this early stage, what hope is there? Stil, like Brian Simpson says, the new season will bring with it the usual hyperbole which masks the cracks. Sad. http://gregtheoharis.wordpress.com/2010/06/18/fabio/

Comment by laticsbrian 2010-07-08 12:08:25

I agree, the development of players at so called top clubs between the ages of 18-21 is a real problem. All too often they are loaned out with little thought to the impact on their development: thinking stops at "they need first team games". The risk is they pick up bad habits. More thought needs to be given to how this group is developed, perhaps with loans to European leagues so that they develop more broadly as footballers and people. The point about some success in the younger age groups is well made, but Trevor Brooking has doubts about the quality coming through in the period until the U-17s are ready.

Comment by paul123 2010-07-08 13:08:53

'The assertions of the world standings of England's players' seems to have diverted their attention from actually doing what the most successful coach they've ever played under asked them to do, thinking they could just complain as and when they wanted. It's all very well complaining if you are genuinely one of the world's best players, but none of the England players have yet proved that to be so, so a little less whining and and more concentration on the job in hand would have been a good start. John Terry has won nothing on the international stage and is a perfect example of how not to conduct one's self without a trophy or two to qualify whatever one happens to be mouthing off about.

Comment by madmickyf 2010-07-12 03:33:20

The problem is that veracious monster known as the English Premier League which always puts it's own interests ahead of those of the England team. The FA created this monster and now they can't control it but don't expect any acknowledgment that they f**ked up any time soon!

Related articles

Bobby Robson film offers smiles, tears and plenty of fond memories
Embed from Getty Images // Watching the elegantly put together More Than A Manager highlights why Robson was so revered by fans, players and...
Graham Taylor: In his own words
Peloton Publishing, £18.99Reviewed by David HarrisonFrom WSC 375, April 2018Buy the book The untimely loss of Graham Taylor in January 2017...
Alan Ball: The man in the white boots by David Tossell
Hodder & Stoughton, £20Reviewed by Mark O’BrienFrom WSC 374, March 2018Buy the book Early on in this detailed and warm biography...