THE HALF DECENT FOOTBALL MAGAZINE

25 February ~ Being a long-suffering York City fan, I'm delighted that we are finally pushing for promotion. But the run-in is looking ominous, with our FA Trophy quarter-final with Barrow being called off with alarming regularity. Indeed, the harsh winter has become the biggest obstacle to success in the Blue Square Premier this year and the margin for error in the Conference is slight.

With only two promotion places up for grabs, frozen pitches are becoming the bane of managers’ lives. So it's time for the FA examine whether a 46-game season is practical at this level. Of course, it is not just Blue Square Premier sides completing this number of games over the course of a campaign, with the three divisions directly below the Premier League all doing likewise. However, due to the lack of funds available to non-League sides for pitch maintenance, the arctic conditions are far more likely to result in called-off matches. Undersoil heating is an almost unheard of luxury for Conference teams.

For a club such as York, stuck in the doldrums of the Conference since 2004 but currently in third place, the fewer distractions the better. But midweek games will be the norm until the end of the season and a potentially lucrative return to Wembley in the FA Trophy is likely to have a detrimental effect on the promotion push.

With only two going up, a club could miss out on automatic promotion by one point, finishing second, and still stay in the Conference. Throw in the fact that Oxford and Luton draw crowds the envy of most League Two clubs – York, Mansfield, AFC Wimbledon, Cambridge and Wrexham don’t do too badly in this respect either – and a 42- or 38-game season makes more sense for a league full of well-supported sides, freeing up space to then be allocated to rearranged games during the winter months.

As one of the privileged few who can still remember the ethereal feeling of staring at a League Cup scoreboard at Old Trafford that read Manchester United 0 York City 3, being robbed of promotion by the weather and a crammed fixture list would be a bitter pill to swallow. Adam Bushby

Comments (2)
Comment by Grimmer 2010-02-25 20:30:03

As a fellow sufferer I have the same concerns about York's run in but there are a couple of reasons why I'd like to see the division remain the size it is.

Clubs make their money by playing games. Less games means less income. Also in a smaller division York may well have been relegated last year as they finished 1 point above 20th.

Swings and roundabouts.

Comment by The Anonymous Don 2010-02-25 21:38:12

If the FA are going to do anything, perhaps leaning on the Football League to make a 46 game season worthwhile by offering four promotion places - the same number of teams relegated from the Conference, and the same number promoted from the division above.

It would have the effect of cutting down the deadwood that seems to have gathered at the bottom of League 2, and create a more healthy exchange of clubs between the two dicisions.

Of course we will lose the novelty factor of a side that spent their entire history in Non-League football finally gaining a place in the 92, but the flipside would be if they turn out not to be worthy of their place they will find their way back down quick enough...

Related articles

Nothing beats the giddy excitement of seeing an orange football used in snow
Better facilities have led to the disappearance of a much-loved tradition over the winter months, as Neil Andrews explained in WSC 312, February...
York and Stockport’s glory days long gone as they struggle in National League North
Both clubs were hoping this season would see them recover from their rapid declines but their starts suggest tough campaign lies ahead 8...
How York City went from brink of League One to National League North
York’s 2-2 draw with Forest Green at the weekend means they will start next season in the sixth tier for the first time. In January 2017,...