THE HALF DECENT FOOTBALL MAGAZINE

31 January ~ Over the last season or so an odd change has come over referees. They have become increasingly reluctant to show yellow cards in the first half of a match. We all recognise the sign language. The crossed arm swoosh indicating cut out the misbehaviour, the single finger showing a final chance and, finally, the point to prior crime scenes reminding the player of all the previous chances the referee wasted before putting his pencil to work.

Instead of a booking for a reckless tackles or persistent fouling, referees now favour a stern talking to. But I can never fathom what exactly is being said that might be news to the player. "Any more of that and you are booked!" would suffice, but instead there is often a lengthy monologue while the player stares aimlessly at the grass.

This little chat does not have to happen every week for 38-plus weeks, unless players really are so stupid that they forget what they have been told the week before about foul play. Although last season I did hear a referee in a League Two match say "No fouling, lads!" as a corner was about to be taken, so it may be that these simple rules have to be reiterated. In which case he could give the speech to both teams at once in the tunnel, allowing him free rein to dish out a yellow the first time a player shows he was not paying attention.

I have a theory to explain referees' keenness to talk. The implementation of the FA’s Respect campaign has the target of improving behaviour and the relationship between players and referees. What better way to do that than reduce one of the things that drives a wedge between the two – namely, the implementation of the latter’s authority on the former.

Players are less likely to disrespect a referee if he lets them away with a bit of dangerous play or persistent fouling. Instead he becomes a collaborator, only calling in the crime if he absolutely has to. Consequently the leniency in recording on-pitch crimes means the overall caution figures over a season is reduced and the FA can proudly trumpet that the Respect campaign has been a success.

Statistics at Premier League level show that bookings have fallen year on year over the last three completed campaigns. But has behaviour improved – or are the figures just being manipulated by the use of a verbal "orange card"? Steve Wilson

Comments (3)
Comment by Etienne 2010-01-31 13:03:29

"Players are less likely to disrespect a referee if he lets them away with a bit of dangerous play or persistent fouling."

I really don't think that's true. Players lose respect for refs if they don't think they are in control of the match. Maybe the player who isn't booked for a reckless tackle might be slightly better disposed towards the ref, but the opposition are unlikely to.

Comment by madmickyf 2010-02-01 01:08:16

You should see the refs in the Australian A-League, they are so adverse to giving cards out that you'd think the things were coated in a deadly poison! Even outright thuggery that would get a red in any European league is acceptable here, especially if the perpetrator is Kevin Muscat.

Comment by davidkeyes 2010-02-01 06:51:10

Refereeing is not just about handing out cards. In what you interpret as unnecessary conversations, referees are often having meaningful discussions with players, e.g. calming them down when they are riled up, letting them know that they saw a previous foul but played the advantage, etc. Yes, the body language can be a bit exaggerated at times but the usefulness of a short chat with an out of control player can do a lot of good -- and even prevent the need to use cards later on in the game.

Related articles

Hopes for 2018 ~ part one
Embed from Getty Images // A failed World Cup, underdogs having their day and free drinks during VAR decisions – WSC contributors on what...
Life during wartime: how the Second World War exposed football’s regional divides
Embed from Getty Images // Despite its ability to raise public spirits, maintaining a coherent league programme proved problematic between 1939...
Referees’ tolerance of foul play annoyed fans and blighted 1950s matches
Embed from Getty Images // Restrained use of yellow cards by officials meant any caution was headline news but that attitude was not always for...