18 December 2009 ~ For a club that has made a habit of not so much shooting itself in the foot as hacking it off with a rusty knife, it is appropriate that this week marks the tenth anniversary of one of the most farcical episodes in West Ham’s history. Not many people would remember Manny Omoyinmi, but for his introduction in the 113th minute of a League Cup quarter-final against Aston Villa that West Ham won on penalties. Omoyinmi didn’t miss a penalty, or an easy chance or score an own-goal. In fact, he didn’t do very much at all. What he had done, though, was play in the competition while on loan at Gillingham earlier in the season.

Inexplicably West Ham had not realised Omoyinmi was cup-tied. The news emerged two days after the game, and those picking up their newspapers on that Friday morning were accompanied by a very sudden feeling of nausea. The Aston Villa chairman Doug Ellis pressed for West Ham’s elimination, but after discussions with the West Ham chairman Terry Brown, Football League secretary David Dent and Premier League chairman Dave Richards, he settled for a replay.

Harry Redknapp, the West Ham manager, bemoaned a “cock-up”, not that he was attributing blame to himself, as well he might have done. How could he not have known what one of his players was getting up to at Gillingham – then again, how did Omoyinmi manage to forget?

It was the pointlessness of the substitution that baffled. In his seven minutes on the pitch, Omoyinmi only touched the ball twice and did not take a penalty in the shoot-out. He was almost too inconsequential to deserve the pariah status in which he was instantly held. This was his one appearance for West Ham that season, and he only scored two goals in five years. He was soon ushered down to the lower leagues and retired in 2006.

As for Redknapp, he emerged with his reputation intact, and instead it fell to the club secretary Graham Mackrell, Sheffield Wednesday’s secretary at the time of the Hillsborough disaster, and the football secretary Alison O’Dowd to resign. The pair had accepted responsibility for a small error with a huge price.

All this sadly detracted from one of the most entertaining games that year. Villa took the lead through Ian Taylor, before Frank Lampard equalised. Then in stoppage time, Dion Dublin volleyed in what was surely Villa’s winner, only for West Ham instantly to win a penalty, converted by Paolo Di Canio. In the ensuing shoot-out, Villa’s villain was ironically Gareth Southgate, whose kick was saved by Shaka Hislop. Neither player knew it was all for nothing.

Supporters who could prove they were at the first match were let into the replay for free, but the outcome was predictable. Villa won 3-1 in extra-time, this time David James saving a Di Canio penalty that would have made it 2-2. A fat lot of good it did Villa though – they promptly lost their semi-final to Leicester City. A little oversight has never been so costly. Jacob Steinberg

Comments (2)
Comment by bearlion 2009-12-18 12:52:55

"win a penalty" is spot on - a shocking dive from Paul Kitson. Which of course made victory in the rematch all the more sweet.

At the time I'd just started seeing a girl who happened to be a West Ham fan. We were still at the "making out" on the sofa stage and the TV was on in the background. This would have been a day or so after the 2nd game and although I was concentrating on the job in hand, my attention was drawn by the fact that the goals were about to be shown. The dilemma was obvious but I couldn't help it: I'd only seen them in the ground so I had to untangle myself and watch. She didn't seem to mind.

Comment by JacobSteinberg 2009-12-18 15:02:50

bearlion - I haven't been able to see highlights of this game for ages as I've only got the season review on video, which unfortunately doesn't work any more... However the match reports I read from this game didn't mention a dive by Kitson. Although I was up the other end, so, really, I have no idea.

What also added a little spice to the game was the seemingly interminable mid-table battle between West Ham and Villa at the time. In 97-98 you finished above us by a point to get into Europe, and we did the same the next year. Along the way, most of our games were draws - and mostly still are. What's more, we played you again at UP in the league three days after the replay. Ian Taylor, who'd scored three times over the two cup games, scored again, and Di Canio equalised late on. It was like a low-rent version of the Chelsea-Liverpool saga.

Related articles

Old Too Soon, Smart Too Late: My Story by Kieron Dyer
with Oliver Holt Headline, £20Reviewed by Gavin BarberFrom WSC 377, July/August 2018Buy the book Kieron Dyer comes across in these pages as...
Graham Taylor: In his own words
Peloton Publishing, £18.99Reviewed by David HarrisonFrom WSC 375, April 2018Buy the book The untimely loss of Graham Taylor in January 2017...
The best and worst moments of 2017 ~ part one
Embed from Getty Images // From Scotland’s failures to the triumph of England’s Under-17s, via John Terry, astounding Cup runs and...