29 November 2009 ~ You don't need a particularly long memory to remember Scottish football's (last) Darkest Hour. In an attempt to appear contemporary and relevant and just like their more illustrious English counterparts, the SFA appointed Bertie Vogts to take charge of the nation's football hopes between 2002 and 2004, and then crush them. Does the end of George Burley's reign hold a candle to that shambles? It is certainly a dark time, with the general attitude of most being that things are only bound to get better under a new manager, be it Calderwood, Collins or Levein, because they really can't get any worse.

Time, you would think, for the SFA to put their heads below the ramparts, make no further comment on national matters for the winter and have a quiet, considered think about the best person to replace Burley. We don't have another friendly until March. Reflect on about the best way to take the national team forward, in terms of personnel and philosophy and how to manage the latest transitional period in our country's tortured quest to compete at another major tournament.

Apparently, the SFA doesn't share this view. Chief executive Gordon Smith recently popped up to say: "The new manager will definitely have a say in who he wants to play." Nothing too controversial there, is there? Not until it's noted that Smith was being quizzed on a potential return for Barry Ferguson and Alan McGregor, banned from being selected for Scotland again on account of a late-night drinking session and then flicking V-signs at cameras from their demoted position on the Scotland bench. Smith went on to say: "If a new manager comes in, I'm quite sure that they will be given the licence to pick whoever they want, provided the people you've mentioned who are out of the scene just now do want to be involved."

It might be argued that banning Ferguson and McGregor being selected for Scotland again was a punishment too heavy for the crime. It wasn't all Smith's idea either, having initially backed Burley's dropping of the pair to the bench, only to be compelled to further action by SFA chairman George Peat and plenty of complaining Scotland fans in light of the gestures the players made while sitting there. A united uproar, a united front, an SFA ban. It's one of the few events that a lot of people could agree on in relation to Scotland throughout a dire qualifying campaign. Even then, it was a bit of a mess.

It seems even messier now, given that the SFA apparently didn't mean it. New managers are more than deserving of a clean slate, but backtracking on Ferguson and McGregor only adds to the disarray already around the international setup. "That? Oh, that was Burley's thing," Smith might as well have said. “We're going to overlook all those unsavoury parts of his time in charge, like when we had to discipline professional footballers for bringing the nation's football into disrepute."

Of course, there's no guarantee that either Ferguson or McGregor will get in another Scotland side, but for Smith to just dismiss their ban out of hand, associating it with a manager he installed and still supported until last week is astonishing. As is saying that it's actually up to those "who are out of the scene just now" to decide if they want to be involved. It is sycophantic to over-rated players and insulting to Scotland fans. The search for a new manager starts here. There should also be a hunt underway for the organisation, consistency and backbone that has deserted the SFA. Rob Macdonald

Comments (5)
Comment by Broon 2009-11-29 23:32:52

It's never difficult to criticise the SFA but I think this is a little harsh. The reality is - whoever the new manager is will demand the right to pick Boyd, McGregor and/or Ferguson as part of the job. The Scotland job is tough enough as it is without handicapping ourselves by keeping three obvious picks sidelined. So the real criticism should be aimed at George Peat, who was behind the whole Life Ban thing, not pausing to think for a second that it would actually be unenforceable unless Scotland qualified for everything under Burley and life was a bed of roses.

And - well, I suppose you are criticising him as the president of the organisation - but the unenforceable decision was made months ago, and it was plainly ludicrous at the time. Peat should've been criticised for it at the time; all Smith is doing now is earnestly answering a journalist's question, which involves the acknowledgement of his own boss's failure.

Comment by The Exploding Vole 2009-11-30 11:07:54

When did Berti Vogts acquire the e in his forename?

Comment by TartanMackem 2009-11-30 11:21:49

Unduly harsh criticism here. It is entirely reasonable that the new manager will expect to have full control over team selection, and the right to pick whoever he wants if he believes it to be of benefit to the team.

Ferguson's time may be over, but as long as Craig Gordon continues to get injured, and Miller/Iwelumwo continue to be unable to hit a barn door, the lads Boyd and McGregor are going to be needed.

Scotland fans will soon forget their deeds if the 3 players contribute towards a successful qualification.

Comment by Dalef65 2009-11-30 16:49:53

Whatever the SFA do they should not appoint Craig Levein.
He was hopeless at Leicester.The moment he stepped out of his SPL comfort zone he was comletely out of his depth

Comment by Mr Beast 2009-12-01 13:44:29

The only person who has sidelined Boyd is Boyd himself.

Mind you, if I'd been kept on the bench behind Iwelumo I'd probably have been a bit miffed too. But I wouldn't have flounced out like a big sulky wean.

Related articles

Lifted Over The Turnstiles: Scotland’s football grounds in the black & white era
by Steve FinanDC Thomson, £15.99Reviewed by Kevin DonnellyFrom WSC 380, November 2018Buy the book On first seeing this book, I worried that...
Adventures In The Golden Age by Archie Macpherson
Scotland in the World Cup finals 1974-1998Black and White, £11.99Reviewed by Alan PatulloFrom WSC 379, September 2018Buy the book Another...
Scotland settle in to life as the warm-up act with only tiny glimmers of hope
Embed from Getty Images // Friendlies against World Cup qualifiers Mexico and Peru highlight how much work Alex McLeish still has to do to get...