Thursday 17 September ~

Tonight's Europa League matches have generated more media interest than is usually given to Europe's secondary club competition but it has nothing to do with the new league format and silly name change. The games will be watched with keen interest because they will involve two extra officials stationed behind the goals. The scheme has been tried out in Under-19 matches and if successful will be introduced in all European leagues. UEFA president Michel Platini's enthusiasm for the idea suggests that he has already decided that it will be a success.

The goal-line gawpers will communicate by radio link but the referee will still have to decide whether to act on their advice. In a sense UEFA's plan is a refinement of a process that has been enacted at most professional football matches for more than a century. There are already several hundred experts behind each goal who have clear views of every incident which they are quite prepared to communicate. It's likely that some of their attention will now be turned towards the man standing in front of them, and in some cases obscuring their view, rather than the man on the pitch with the whistle.

Platini seems to believe that the presence of extra officials will discourage simulation, the blight on the modern game that seems to produce anguished headlines on an almost daily basis. The depth of UEFA's concern about this issue was demonstrated when they rushed to ban Eduardo for diving to win a penalty in a Champions League qualifier – before rescinding the punishment after an appeal. Wise heads prevailed in the Eduardo case because the precedent set would have led to chaos. Every penalty awarded would be subject to even more minute scrutiny than it currently receives, with daily demands for players to be fined, banned, tagged and, eventually, tarred and feathered, while referees would be thoroughly undermined by having major decisions reassessed.

Platini has even used referees' supposed fallability to justify the use of extra officials, saying: "For years players have cheated because the referees were not of good enough quality... with the extra officials close by they will take the right decisions." Referees are excoriated now because, as aggrieved managers never tire of pointing out, mistakes cost money. The loss of income that results from a wrong decision hasn't yet been represented as an algebraic formula but teams of statisticians are working towards it in thinktanks funded by the wealthiest European clubs. In the meantime there seems little point in entertaining the hope that football administrators will one day be of "good enough quality" to not want to fiddle about with the laws for the benefit of the privileged few.

Comments (3)
Comment by manandvans 2009-09-17 13:47:35

"Wise heads prevailed in the Eduardo case because the precedent set would have led to chaos."

If it meant players, of all clubs, who persistently cheat getting punished then putting up with a bit of chaos is no bad thing.

Howard Johnson: Y'know, Nietzsche says: "Out of chaos comes order." (Blazing Saddles).

Comment by Broon 2009-09-17 21:40:57

Having just watched Leighton Baines go down in the box not two or three feet away from one of these new behind-the-goal officials - it looked like a penalty to me, OR a dive, the defender didn't win the tackle and Baines didn't just 'slip' - and the assistant looked completely blank and did absolutely nothing, I feel comfortable extrapolating that this experiment is a massive waste of time.

Comment by Nurse Duckett 2009-09-18 12:15:15

I agree with manandvans.

UEFA should not have rescinded Eduardo's ban - just gives carte blanche to the divers to carry on as per. Of course they should have made a strong clear statement about this at the start of the season.

It should be no reflection on the referee if he's been conned, but a few lengthy bans based after-match evidence just might stop "simulation" (nothing else has, so far). Surely worth a try, even on a one-season trial and review basis.

I'm all for creating employment opportunities, but is it realistic to have an extra two officials for games at every level? I wouldn't want to see different ways of working for certain levels of competition only; same applies to goal-line technology.

Related articles

Photo of the week ~ Hertha Berlin supporters outside Olympic Stadium
Hertha Berlin 1-0 Sporting, Olympic Stadium, Europa League, 2009 Two home fans standing outside the stadium before Hertha Berlin's match against...
Hopes for 2018 ~ part one
Embed from Getty Images // A failed World Cup, underdogs having their day and free drinks during VAR decisions – WSC contributors on what...
Referees’ tolerance of foul play annoyed fans and blighted 1950s matches
Embed from Getty Images // Restrained use of yellow cards by officials meant any caution was headline news but that attitude was not always for...