WSC Logo

wsc355 medrec

Sign up for the WSC Weekly Howl

A small portion of despair and enlightenment delivered to your inbox every Friday


First name

Ireland fans split on Trapattoni's tactics

Republic of Ireland v Germany, 7.45pm

icon traptac12 October ~ With just one defeat in their previous 21 qualifier group games under Giovanni Trapattoni, one might think that the Republic of Ireland fans would be looking forward to the visit of Germany. However, the previous game was a fortuitous win away against Kazakhstan and that followed the worst performance of any team at the European Championship. It means hope is in short supply ahead of tonight’s game at the Aviva Stadium. Ireland are rated an almost-unheard-of 13/2 with the bookmakers to win at home.

Throughout Trapattoni's reign the fans have been roughly split into two groups. There are those that see him as a pragmatist who makes the most of what he has, knowing that Ireland will rarely play opponents off the field. Then there are those – led by TV pundit Eamon Dunphy – who feel that success and good football are not mutually exclusive but that the Italian is too suspicious of creative players.

The general mood fluctuated in the summer. Qualification brought greater acceptance of Trapattoni's methods but the losses to Croatia, Spain and Italy signalled more dissent, while the smash-and-grab in Astana didn't help to quieten critics. Trapattoni has done little to curry favour, seemingly falling out with one player per international break; Shane Long is the latest to feel his cold shoulder. Assistant Marco Tardelli does not help matters. Last month he made a ham-fisted attempt through the press to get Damien Duff to reconsider his retirement, while this week he told the media that Robbie Keane's injury was the result of a Paul McShane tackle, only to later claim he was joking.

It says much that the injury to captain and record scorer Keane is seen as a blessing in disguise even if it is Jon Walters, rather than the popular Long, who will lead the line. None of Keane, Duff, Richard Dunne or Shay Given are involved for the first time in over a decade. Another big change is that Trapattoni, for whom playing strikers as wide midfielders was previously his most daring experiment, has moved from the 4-4-2 he has been wedded to for competitive games.

Instead, Ireland will play in a 4-3-3, with wide men Aiden McGeady and Simon Cox (the manager is yet to be convinced by James McClean) supporting Walters. Almost as surprising is that, where the 4-4-2 usually featured two defensive midfielders in Glenn Whelan and Keith Andrews, the latter is now joined by James McCarthy and Keith Fahey. Conspiracy theorists will believe that Trapattoni is doing it in a game which will likely be lost no matter what the system. However it pans out, the reaction will be interesting. Denis Hurley

Comment on 12-10-2012 13:23:24 by peakevilla #719614
Ireland are on a hiding to nothing tonight, and even though the record is good in qualifiers, the fact remains that the players do not know where they're supposed to be on the pitch. Trap is past his sell-by date, and should retire. Germany will enjoy themselves at the "bedpan", and we could end up losing by a large margin. As for media opinion, Liam Brady continues to defend Trap, whilst Dunphy has no time for the man and his tactics, and rightly so, in my opinion. John Giles doesn't want to upset anyone, simple as that. Oktoberfest in Dublin.

Discuss this article

You must be logged in to comment. Please register if you don't have an account yet.


© When Saturday Comes Limited 2016 | Contact | Privacy & cookies | Sitemap | Managed hosting by Latitude