THE HALF DECENT FOOTBALL MAGAZINE

2 June ~ Tuesday night was slightly disappointing in New York. Hundreds of photographers, tourists and celestial geeks gathered on street corners to witness Manhattanhenge, a biannual event where the sunset aligns perfectly with the borough's east-west street grid. Then, at the appointed hour, storm clouds rolled over New Jersey, completely obliterating any view. But the US Open Cup made up for it. As MLS clubs entered America's oldest ongoing football tournament at the third-round stage, many fielded weakened sides against lower-division opposition. They clearly shouldn't have done. Of the 14 top-division teams playing on Tuesday, seven were knocked out at the first time of asking.

In his history of the game in the US, Soccer in a Football World, David Wangerin claims that the American game is "careless with its fragile history". Nowhere is this more obvious than with the Open Cup. The competition began in 1914 and has received little attention through its 98-year history. It was ignored by the old North American Soccer League (NASL) – which now serves as the second tier – and continues unchanged to this day.

While teams such as New Jersey's Cowboy Club and the Young Men's Catholic Total Abstinence Society FC of Massachusetts are long gone, names such as the Croatian Eagles and New York Greek American still evoke US soccer's ethnic past.

This week, New York, Philadelphia and Seattle won comfortably, but many other MLS teams struggled. On Tuesday the Carolina RailHawks beat LA Galaxy 2-1 and the Michigan Bucks knocked out Chicago Fire in injury-time, while the Dayton Dutch Lions scored two goals in the last 12 minutes to win over Columbus Crew. Both FC Dallas and Real Salt Lake lost at home by a two-goal margin, 2-0 to the Charlotte Eagles and 3-1 to the Minnesota Stars respectively. San Antonio Scorpions can now claim to be the best team in Texas after beating Houston Dynamo 1-0.

In the most dramatic game, New England Revolution took a 3-0 lead in the first period of extra-time against the third-level Harrisburg City Islanders. But Harrisburg fought back with three goals in the last nine minutes and won the penalty shoot-out. On Wednesday, Cal FC, the amateur team run by former US international Eric Wynalda, scored the first-ever goal by a fifth-tier United States Adult Soccer Association club against an MLS opponent, and beat the Portland Timbers. Eight MLS teams have now been eliminated.

While New York Greek American have won the cup four times and New York Pancyprian-Freedoms on three occasions, the New York Red Bulls are the only original MLS franchise to have never won a trophy. With so many top-level clubs already out, this could be an opportunity for the Red Bulls to break that unwanted record. But if the competition continues as it has this week, the next Open Cup champion may well play in the NASL or below. Ed Upright

Comments (1)
Comment by FCKarl 2012-06-06 07:43:37

Good article. It really has been a cup of total upsets to date. And now, as they say -- "hot off the presses!" In other words, just off the news wires:

5 June 2012 -- For the second time in a week, USL PRO's Harrisburg City Islanders took an MLS team to overtime and for the second time prevailed in the Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup. Last week, they came back from 3-0 down after the first overtime period to tie the New England Revolution 3-3 and prevail on penalty kicks. This time, Harrisburg got overtime goals from Gambian Sainey Touray -- his second goal of the game -- and Zimbabwean Lucky Mkosana to defeat the MLS New York Red Bulls, 3-1, on Tuesday night in the cup's fourth round.

The Harrisburg City Islanders beat the Red Bulls for the second time in the U.S. Open Cup and claimed its fifth MLS victim in club history. Harrisburg beat D.C. United, 1-0, in 2007, New England, 2-1, in 2009 and the Red Bulls, 1-0, in 2010. (So -- the Red Bulls should have been well forewarned prior to this June 5 encounter yesterday.)

The City Islanders will now face MLS's Philadelphia Union, to which they are affiliated, in the cup quarterfinals on June 26 in Chester, Pennsylvania.

Now...if Seattle also get beat by that upstart amateur club from California, well, well. We'll have a new "Rocky" story on our hands.

Related articles

Phil Rawlins: from Stoke director to Orlando and MLS
The Florida club’s debut this season is the culmination of a long journey 19 March ~ When over 62,000 Floridians packed into Citrus Bowl...
New York Red Bulls fans protest against owners
Sacking of coach Mike Petke proves a breaking point 24 January ~ The new MLS season will begin in March with two sets of unhappy fans in New York....
Concacaf Champions League struggling
DC United v Tauro example of problems faced 26 September ~ "Road to FIFA Club World Cup" reads one of the ad hoardings in DC United's Robert F...