THE HALF DECENT FOOTBALL MAGAZINE

4 December ~ Sunderland supporters at Molineux will be buoyant today following the arrival of Martin O’Neill. There should also be a veneer of sadness as the club witnesses the end of an era for one its greatest figures. No, not Steve Bruce. The waves had washed his footprints clear within 30 minutes of his sacking. His departure, however, marked the moment Niall Quinn completed his quiet retreat from the helm. The pro-forma offer of thanks to Bruce was made not by Quinn, the man who appointed him, but by Ellis Short, the club’s American owner. Short became chairman in October, shifting Quinn into a meaningless international development role.

Sidelining the Irishman was a key step as Short reshaped the club. Much work has been done recently on the club's executive structure. The credentials of Short's new backroom team appear impressive, from David Miliband to Margaret Byrne, the club's new chief executive, who was recently voted onto the FA Council as a Premier League representative.

This, however, is dry, corporate stuff. It is a far cry from Quinn's first days in charge when he was backed by a beery bunch of loaded Irish builder mates. Quinn's battle-cry was populist, inherited from his time spearheading Peter Reid's Millennium revival. Under Reid, the club revelled in a comically foul-mouthed dressing room, two wingers and a big man-little man combination up front. The brief frenzy revitalised Quinn just as football cynicism was starting to seep through his aging bones.

His first act as chairman, the appointment of Roy Keane, was of a piece with this frenzy. Players came and went at dizzying speed. It was too much for Short (by now owner), who grew tired of Keane's erratic nature. Many fans had grown weary too, though few questioned the initial coup of bringing him to the club. Opinions were more divided by Bruce. Quinn seemed delighted. He saw in Bruce an old-school type, but one with a more stable character. He misjudged his man. The frenzy continued. Bruce was as much a shopaholic as Keane. Loan signings provided a brief sugar-rush, followed by the inevitable low.

Quinn's high-octane rhetoric ultimately failed to dispel the pessimism ingrained in Sunderland’s supporters. These have been comparatively successful years for the club. But the mood at the Stadium of Light has rarely sparkled. O'Neill's frenetic energy might change that, offering hope that Short’s manoeuvring can disperse the growing gloom. But it wasn’t Short at St James Park on November 18, 2000 looping a header over a scrambling Shay Given, on one of Sunderland’s finest folk-lore days. It was Quinn and a part of me mourns that this proud club is no longer run by a hero but by a hedgefund manager. Joe Boyle

Comments (4)
Comment by Red Adder 2011-12-05 08:53:29

Just hope that Bruce doesn't end up with Ipswich. Fortunately he will consider us too down-market though if you analyse his record I can't see why anyone would want him, unless you want his latest mega-whine about how the ref cost him the match.

Comment by Paul Rowland 2011-12-05 13:22:26

I'm not really a student on the subject of Steve Bruce's managerial career - it's not the must riveting of subjects is it? - but my perception is that he's generally done a reasonable job wherever he's gone. Did OK at Huddersfield before resigning. Did OK at Palace before resigning. Ditto Birmingham and Wigan. Most fans of clubs he's managed in the past seem to be critical of him not so much for his lack of competence - more for his lack of loyalty.

(Or is that just my perception? If I were a student of Steve Bruce's managerial career, or a fan of one of the clubs he resigned from, would I still be saying that? Maybe I would and maybe I wouldn't. I don't know. I'm happy to be corrected if my perception is at odds with reality.)

Comment by Jongudmund 2011-12-06 12:58:40

The interesting thing about Steve Bruce is that until now he always seems to have left one job for another. Rarely has he been pushed.

However annoying he may have been in his post-match comments on MOTD, I've always felt he must have something about him.

Comment by tempestinaflathat 2011-12-07 13:19:45

Steve Bruce isn't a terrible manager; his record is testament to that. Instead, he inhabits a grey world that is barely recognised either by fans or commentators. Steve Bruce is competent. He's adequate. He's not bad, really, all things considered. He's kind of okay.

And, unfortunately, that's probably enough to take a fairly well-funded club to a reasonable level of stability in the Premier League for a couple of years, but no more than that. He'd probably settle in fine at one of the larger second division sides. But at the top level, he's ultimately just a little bit out of his depth - only a little, but enough.

Related articles

Massively Violent & Decidedly Average by Lee Howey
Biteback Publishing, £12.99Reviewed by Ed UprightFrom WSC 375, April 2018Buy the book One of Lee Howey’s most cherished memories is...
Simon Grayson looks to calm Sunderland chaos ahead of opening Derby test
Embed from Getty Images // The Black Cats’ signings have been solid rather than spectacular as they look to steady themselves in the...
There’s always last year ~ Premier League 2016-17
Embed from Getty Images Chelsea surprise seemingly everyone at the top as the José Mourinho v Pep Guardiola battle fails to materialise...