26 November ~ As unlikely managerial appointments go, the recruitment of Sam Allardyce by West Ham has to be up there with Leeds' decision in 1974 to employ Brian Clough. A club that has all too often tolerated attractive football as a substitute for success seemed an unlikely destination for a pragmatic, results-driven manager. That Hammers fans welcomed him with open arms – a poll at the time of his appointment indicated an approval rate of 84 per cent – was testament to supporters' thirst for change. Some 100 days into his tenure, a run-of-the-mill away-day trip to Coventry's Ricoh Arena was watched by 6,000 travelling supporters, suggesting that this approval rating still holds.

Having lost quality players such as Scott Parker, Thomas Hitzlsperger and Demba Ba in the summer, a typical Allardyce line-up now blends impressive new recruits (Sam Baldock, Abdoulaye Faye and Matt Taylor among others) with players rejuvenated under his tutelage. Many fans hoped for, and assumed, a complete overhaul of Avram Grant's squad, but the likes of James Tomkins, Winston Reid and Julien Faubert seem to have been reborn.

West Ham are currently second in the Championship, with the division's best away record. Their home form to date has not been that of a top-six side. Games where the Hammers have been held at Upton Park have betrayed unease among fans frustrated with an unfamiliar style of play. It has not been the incessant hoof-ball that some feared, but all too often victories have not been earned through creativity and flair, but by packing the midfield and stealing a scrappy goal. Effective or not, the mindset of many supporters remains stubbornly rooted in the era of Ron Greenwood and John Lyall.

The West Ham marketing team (never ones to miss a chance to tap in to the nostalgia of their target audience) have been advertising tickets for today's game against Derby County under the strapline: "Get Ready To Face Cloughie's County". Brian's son Nigel brings his Derby team to Upton Park having won just once in the last nine games. West Ham fans will expect nothing less than three points.

The experiences of teams that have visited E13 so far this season suggest that Clough would do well to ditch his dad's philosophy, and line his team up to frustrate West Ham. When relegation strugglers Bristol City parked the bus earlier this month, they came away with a rare away point. When fifth-placed Blackpool tried to make a game of it and play the ball out from defence, they were summarily beaten 4-0.

Famously, Clough senior once said: "If God had wanted us to play football in the clouds, he'd have put grass up there." Allardyce may share Brian Clough's self-belief, but the similarity ends there. As West Ham's promotion campaign continues apace, the feeling among the Upton Park faithful remains one of ambivalence. Neil Fairchild

Comments (3)
Comment by Karlheinz Riedle 2011-11-27 11:54:48

"Attractive football"? For the past 3 or 4 years I've watched Mark Noble and Scott Parker kick lumps out of everything that moved, before lobbing long balls over the top to Carlton Cole (and before him, Marlon Harewood).

Comment by mjfarrow 2011-11-28 20:09:26

As a West Ham fan, it's not poor football that bothers me. We successfully long balled our way out of this division twice in three years under Billy Bonds in the early 90s. He was as grounded in the ways of the academy as any player or manager in West Ham's history and the rock around which Greenwood and Lyall built the team for the best part of two decades.

However, Bonds never tried to dress it up like it was something else, which Allardyce continually insists on doing. Case in point, the game against Crystal Palace in September. We pass it around neatly in our own half but the ball is punted to Carlton Cole when the ball goes forward. Allardyce insisted his was the footballing team when it wasn't. I can take direct football, Pardew played fairly direct, I just don't want to be told I'm watching Barcelona when I'm not, it's just dishonest.

Karlheinz: With a diamond midfield of Parker, Collison, Noble and Behrami and with Di Michele in the hole, Zola tried to play football until injuries and player sales killed his efforts.

Comment by Karlheinz Riedle 2011-11-29 21:17:11

Fair play mjfarrow, you're honest, but with no disrespect West Ham were never my favourite team to play. Not just because we never managed to wrest three points from you in all the games I watched (I missed EVERY occasion where we beat you lot), but also because when you DID win there was a ridiculous amount of kicking, and niggly fouls off the ball - not including the outright savagery displayed byParker and Noble - that went unspotted.

I think that there's too much nostalgia in the press regarding West Ham that harkens back to the days of Greenwood et al that ignores the direct football of the past decade and a half. And that is why God invented the internet, so I could publish my grievances.

Related articles

Old Too Soon, Smart Too Late: My Story by Kieron Dyer
with Oliver Holt Headline, £20Reviewed by Gavin BarberFrom WSC 377, July/August 2018Buy the book Kieron Dyer comes across in these pages as...
Photo of the week ~ Bubbles fill the air at West Ham’s London Stadium
West Ham United 0 Brighton & Hove Albion 3, 20/10/2017, London Stadium, Premier League This photo was taken as part of the Match of the Month...
Would relegation be so bad? Fans of Premier League also-rans stuck in limbo
Embed from Getty Images // The top division’s mid-table teams simply make up the numbers, so terrified of the drop that they refuse to take...