THE HALF DECENT FOOTBALL MAGAZINE

16 July ~ They must have had their moments during the "Bank of England" days, but modern-day Sunderland have never been particularly dynamic in the transfer market. In February 2010, the club relied on the goodwill of the Premier League to ratify the last-minute loan of Benjani after "some huge, huge difficulties" with the Stadium of Light fax machine. Sunderland fans are used to deadline-day panic and drawn-out transfer debacle but this summer has been completely different. Nine players had completed moves before the first pre-season friendly. And it's quite a pleasant change.

Every signing, of course, is a risk. And as fans of other clubs have only been too keen to tell me, recruiting almost a whole new team in one summer is an even bigger gamble. But these signings seem thought-out and considered, not as scattergun as they may appear from the outside. I know it's the summer, and that I really should know better, but I'm feeling foolishly optimistic.

The gloom at the start of the break, after selling Jordan Henderson, has been replaced by cheerfulness as we've reinvested (wages notwithstanding) in a mixture of youthful potential and real experience. Our recruits for the future – strikers Connor Wickham and Ji Dong-Won – seem to be genuinely regarded as having a chance of making it. To the ire of the papers Connor Wickham was a long-term Liverpool target who ended up at Sunderland instead.

The former Ipswich player suddenly became less interesting – if he'd moved to Merseyside there would have been photos of him at concerts with Kenny Daglish, like Andy Carroll with a rictus grin at Boyzone in February. At the other end of the pitch our new Ireland international goalkeeper Keiren Westwood, signed from Coventry, has long been regarded as one of the best outside the Premier League.

But the most surprising transfers this summer have been Wes Brown and John O'Shea from Manchester United. O'Shea especially is seen as a player who we wouldn't have been able to sign a couple of years ago. It's hoped that both defenders can calm an occasionally nervy, young side. The dubious attention span of Titus Bramble, for example, may benefit from having a calming and experienced presence alongside him. Steve Bould is still remembered fondly on Wearside after his short but influential spell in 1999-2000 helped a newly promoted side to seventh place. We're looking for a similar role from the ex-Man Utd players, who are much younger than Bould when he arrived.

This squad strengthening should avoid the annual second-half slump that has characterised our last two seasons. In midfield, Craig Gardner, Sebastian Larsson and David Vaughan will hopefully provide goals, crosses and energy respectively. And I see no reason why not. But I'm probably a hopeless case. In February last year I was looking up the "Best of Benjani" on YouTube and blithely predicting great things for our new loanee. He didn't score a goal for Sunderland and became a free agent at the start of this month. So my judgement might be skewed. But my football team have definitely fixed their fax machine. Ed Upright

Comments (3)
Comment by olijoy 2011-07-16 11:41:07

From an outsider looking in, Sunderland's summer transfer activity doesn't really strike me as being that different to that under Keane's years?

If memory serves, in consecutive summers Keane embarked on sprees of a similar scale and signing players of - in my opinion at least - similar calibre: Gordon, Chopra, Jones, Richardson and Bardsley one summer (the latter two arguably of comparable quality to Brown and O'Shea and, like them, representing the more 'dregs' element of Man Utd's squad); McCartney, Ferdinand, Tainio, Cisse and Malbranque the next.

The success of these players contrasted sharply of course, and Bruce and Keane are obviously different bosses, so maybe the change in bosses and a 'lessons learned' mentality may genuinely make the current recruitment drive seem more promising to Sunderland fans. To me though it just looks like more of the same.

Comment by Alex Walker 2011-07-16 22:58:58

As a United fan, I'd have to say there is a gulf in quality between O'Shea and Brown compared to Richardson and Bardsley. The latter two struggled to break into the side, whereas Brown and O'Shea in particular were fixtures in the squad for a decade. O'Shea took over the role of Phil Neville as the clubs 'Mr Dependable', and slotted in wherever he was needed, and always gave a pretty good performance. There are plenty of United fans sorry to see him go.

Comment by Jongudmund 2011-07-17 20:10:58

Plus there's the benefit of signing two players who know each other and have played together for some time. Could be a very shrewd move.

Related articles

Massively Violent & Decidedly Average by Lee Howey
Biteback Publishing, £12.99Reviewed by Ed UprightFrom WSC 375, April 2018Buy the book One of Lee Howey’s most cherished memories is...
Simon Grayson looks to calm Sunderland chaos ahead of opening Derby test
Embed from Getty Images // The Black Cats’ signings have been solid rather than spectacular as they look to steady themselves in the...
There’s always last year ~ Premier League 2016-17
Embed from Getty Images Chelsea surprise seemingly everyone at the top as the José Mourinho v Pep Guardiola battle fails to materialise...

More... Sunderland