3 May ~ Most older Lincoln City fans are still scarred by the events of May 9, 1987, when Torquay United's injury-time goal at home to Crewe Alexandra sent the Imps down to non-League football in the closing seconds of the season. It was the first time all year they'd been bottom, and for me the first time in 17 years of supporting the team that I could recall them having been in Division Four's 24th place. The shock was as great as the timing was poor – they touched the nadir at the very second when automatic relegation from the Football League kicked in for the first time ever.

This coming Saturday will invite Lincoln's fans to relive the trauma. Only a win at home to Aldershot will guarantee safety, but if Lincoln draw or lose, while Barnet overcome a visiting Port Vale side, then they will return to English football's fifth tier. There's a certain symmetry in Barnet being our co-fighters for League status. When Lincoln came straight back up from relegation in 1988, it was thanks to a late slip-up from the north London side at the end of a season when there was little pleasantry between the clubs. The two teams have continued level-pegging ever since.

Including their season in what was then the Vauxhall Conference, the teams have met 30 times in league matches. Lincoln have won 14 of those games, Barnet 13 and there have been three draws. One of Barnet's first ever League games was at Sincil Bank in 1991, where they took revenge for the Conference season by winning 6-0. City eventually laid that humiliation to rest with a 5-0 victory at Underhill in 2006. But the intense rivalry of that Conference season diminished thanks to geographical distance, and the realisation that both teams were perennial fourth-tier strugglers – both on the field and financially – with a few play-off campaigns and the odd short-lived foray to Division 3 thrown in. Barnet have already been down once to non-League and back again. No matter what a few short-brained fans on the fringe might exclaim, solidarity in suffering has become close to the norm at this level, and it would be a heartless follower who crowed at seeing the other team go down.

Lincoln's history includes three earlier occasions when they came straight back up to the Football League after finishing last. In 1909 and 1912 they rejoined the League after one-year absences thanks to re-election. In 1921 they took the Midland League title a year after being voted out, and joined the newly formed Division Three (North). But there are certain records you'd rather not see challenged. The statistics of historical precedent are among the most meaningless in the game, and while the 1987-88 season in the Conference reinvigorated the club with a sense of its worth within the city, there's no guarantee that relegation this year, followed by a poor start next season, won't see a further slump given that home crowds have regularly sunk below 3,000.

The fifth tier looks an altogether tougher place to escape from than it did in 1987, when Lincoln opted to stay professional in a division of relatively obscure part-timers. Now there are numerous ex-League names like Luton, Wrexham, Grimsby, Mansfield, Darlington and York to contend with. All have been or continue to go through their own crises of form and hardship, and meeting them in the sub-League basement will be like film stars running in to fellow celebrities when they show up in rehab. "Don't worry, I'm not planning to stay long," the new arrival might say, and the long-term residents all burst into cynical laughter.

Plenty of teams like Colchester, Shrewsbury, Torquay and Carlisle followed Lincoln's lead by making swift returns to the League, but that's little consolation at a moment when relegation stares at you from up close and the sword of bad form seems irredeemably stuck in a hard, unyielding stone of despair (sorry, this time of year tends to drive a fan to melodrama). Lincoln have taken two points out of a possible 30 in their last ten matches, and have lost all four of their home fixtures in that abominable run. You feel that the only way they'll stay up is if Barnet fail to beat Port Vale. Even that would hardly be a triumph, and would certainly be tempered by empathy for our erstwhile rivals.

At the age of 21, I coped with losing League status by taking a late-afternoon bath and drinking two cans of Red Stripe, a vile drink that suited my mood, but which I haven't touched since. This time I'm better prepared, having already more or less convinced myself that we're going down. Maybe instead of seeking temporary oblivion, I'll take a long walk in the woods while shunning all human contact. And during that time I'll manage to convince myself that next year Lincoln will go straight back up. Because we always do, don't we? Ian Plenderleith

Comments (6)
Comment by jameswba 2011-05-03 15:02:09

I was a semi-regular at Telford Utd in that 87/88 Conference season and saw them play (and lose to) both Lincoln and Barnet. Don't recall if this was the general view at the time but I remember Barnet as a highly entertaining, passing side and Lincoln as solid and uncompromising, with a rigid offside-trap and, in Mick Waitt, a man-mountain of a centre-forward. I also remember thinking at the time of their win at Telford, which was early season, that Lincoln's staying full-time was going to make the difference. Now, they'd be one of probably twenty full-time outfits.

No great preference as to who survives this battle but much empathy with the fans of both clubs.

Comment by Tony C 2011-05-03 15:40:58


On a related note, when Droylsden played their one and only season to date in the National Conference (2007/08) they were one of only four clubs - along with Farsley Celtic, Altricham and Stafford Rangers - who continued as semi-pros in that division.

Needless to say these clubs occupied the bottom four places at the end of the season.

Comment by Lincoln 2011-05-03 17:23:53

I know who I want to stay up, just sad it will be at the expense of Barnet who are a good club.

Comment by Houdi Elbow 2011-05-03 17:45:29

I saw a couple of Lincoln's games in 87-88. That season there was an experiment with a 'no offside from a free kick' rule, the result of which was posting tall players on the goal line and a high ball into the box. Not what was envisaged I guess.

Comment by colinwasp 2011-05-03 22:01:49

As a Barnet suppoter I would dearly love my club to stay up simply because promotion back would be virtually impossible. The only way the club can compete with the top-half of the Conference for players is not financially, but because they can offer them regular League football. As much as I would hate Lincoln to go down, mainly because in the last six games betwen the to at Underhill there has been about forty-odd goals, I feel that they are better placed eographically and financially to come back up.

Sadly, the chairman's ludicrous near-sightednes in appointing, at the start of a season, a manager whose last away League victory coincided with the Regency period, has been our undoing. It's only in the last month or so, with the arrival and departure of Martin Allen and some semblence of guts about the team, that the season has manaed to rise to something other than tedium, desperation and despair.

It's twenty years since we won our last game to taste League football for the first time, and ten years since we got relegated by losing our last game at home to Torquay. I don't know about it being lucky for Spurs when the year ends in 1, but it's certainly bloody terrifying for Bees fans....

Comment by Dave H 2011-05-08 10:59:34

As a Barnet who attended both the games between the clubs back in 87/88 I must admit that I have disliked Lincoln ever since. Lincoln seemed to have signed a team of thuggish basketball players specifically to exploit the offside rule experiment mentioned above.

In the first game at Underhill a terrible tackle broke Barnet midfielder John Margerrison's leg. In the return at Sincil Bank, in the worst refereeing performance I have ever witnessed, Barnet were kicked, punched and fouled from begining to end. At one point a Lincoln defender jumped on Eddie Stein, the Barnet winger's, back in order to bring him down. Barry Fry ran the width of the pitch to join in the ensuing melee. The whole thing was caught on camera yet no action was taken against anyone.
All very suspicious !

Sorry Ian, there is no sympathy for Lincoln in this corner of North London.

Related articles

YouTube team Hashtag United can bring younger fans to non-League matches
Embed from Getty Images // There was scepticism when Spencer Owen's new club entered the Eastern Senior League South, but they could be a force...
Photo of the week ~ Radio Cumbria set up at Rushall Olympic's Dales Lane
Rushall Olympic 1 Workington 0, 17/02/2018, Dales Lane, Northern Premier League Premier Division The team from BBC Radio Cumbria set up their...
Photo of the week ~ Umbrellas needed at Harrogate Railway's Station View
Harrogate Railway 3 Shepshed Dynamo 2, 11/10/2006, Station View Photos by Paul Thompson for WSC PhotographyFollow Paul on TwitterFollow WSC...