26 April ~ When the sad news emerged that Bryan Robson was suffering from throat cancer, the 24-hour news channels understandably headed to Old Trafford. Robson remains the longest-serving captain in Manchester United history. But before becoming United and England captain the midfielder had already spent more than six years cementing his status as a West Bromwich Albion hero. Robson is a genuine two-club legend. It's a phenomenon being jeopardised by the 21st century culture of "too much too soon".

Back in Robson's day, it was not especially unusual for England stars to remain with their first professional club for a considerable time. Fellow international John Barnes played nearly 300 games for Watford before his transfer to Liverpool – making the move three whole years after his wonder goal for England against Brazil in the Maracanã. The Man Utd back four that operated behind Robson when the club lifted its first League title in 26 years is another prime example. Indeed, Paul Parker, Denis Irwin, Gary Pallister and Steve Bruce were all recently named in the "greatest XI" of the clubs they left to join Man Utd. But these were experienced players who between them had made more than 1,000 League appearances before joining United.

Not so nowadays. Players are making that big move earlier and earlier. Of course, at whatever age, there's no guarantee it will work out. Chelsea have operated something of a revolving door policy for young English talent in recent years. The likes of Scott Parker, Steve Sidwell and Shaun Wright-Phillips all arrived at Stamford Bridge with impressive reputations earned at other clubs, only to struggle to make an impact. All three men were in their early 20s but spent what might have been their most fruitful years on the bench (although Scott Parker is coming strong again at the age of 30).

The cycle is in danger of repeating itself with the next generation of English talent. Ex-Fulham man Chris Smalling appears to be a highly capable young defender and he has already jumped the queue ahead of Jonny Evans and Wes Brown at Manchester United. Meanwhile, Chelsea's Daniel Sturridge – already having moved on from Manchester City – has become a firm favourite on loan at Bolton. And yet, Smalling stands little chance of establishing himself ahead of Rio Ferdinand and Nemanja Vidic. Likewise, it would be a brave coach who picked Sturridge ahead of Roman Abramovich's misfiring £50 million pet project, Fernando Torres. As a result, Smalling and Sturridge may be consigned to developing their game on the training ground rather than via regular competitive football.

It's not easy to calculate whether a player will be better off staying at a club where he can play or moving to one where he can learn. Southampton fans know better than most the frustration of the modern reality of losing players in their teens. Theo Walcott and Gareth Bale were both sold while still eligible for the youth team and their progress upon leaving was not immediately obvious. Walcott made 48 league starts in his first five seasons with Arsenal while Bale fared little better with 38 in three seasons. However, Walcott now boasts 16 England caps and Bale is the PFA Player of the Year. Whether they would have made quicker or better progress elsewhere we will never know. What we can say is that, unlike Bryan Robson and his ilk, they are very unlikely to ever be two-club legends. And that seems to me to be something of a shame. Adam Bate

Comments (6)
Comment by Efficient Baxter 2011-04-26 12:21:00

In fairness to Smalling, he's probably played more games for United than he would have done at Fulham. He only got a chance at the Cottage because of the Europa League run and he would not have shifted the formidable CB pairing of Hughes and Hangeland - only City, United and Chelsea have conceded fewer goals than the Fulham defence this season.

Comment by donedmundo 2011-04-26 12:50:43

Couldn't be anything to do with the wages could it?

Comment by JM Footzee 2011-04-26 13:55:30

Good article. I remember watching Kyle Walker and Kyle Naughton put in superb performances for Sheffield United in the 2009 Championship play-off final, only to see them swallowed them up by Spurs and spend much of the subsequent season in the reserves. Both have had stronger seasons this time around, but I feared for them.

I also feel for the masses of foreign talent signed by clubs like Arsenal and Chelsea at a young age. Obviously not all of them are going to make the grade, but they were presumably signed on the basis that they were the among the best in the youth ranks of their country - and not only that, probably the best across their year group internationally. Some make the first-team, but many more are spat out aged 23 having traipsed around various countries on loan feeling homesick and under-performing. That's arguably a greater waste of talent than we see with English players.

They're also simultaneously blocking off opportunities for young English talent in those club's academies. It's a great shame.

Comment by Analogue Bubblebath II 2011-04-26 14:55:11

Decent article, but Smalling will play plenty of football for Man United in the coming years. Ferdinand is plagued by injuries and is also well into his 30s.

Comment by Dalef65 2011-04-26 17:58:03

You could also add Wayne Routledge to the list of these such players.

But really its due to the finances (wages),and the way they are totally unbalanced these days.

Simply put,the big clubs can afford to speculate to accumulate,and they just hoover up the best (or potentailly best)players that are knocking about.
And if they make the odd mistake here and there,they comfort themselves with the thought that they have stopped somebody else getting their hands on the player.

Comment by jameswba 2011-04-27 09:59:04

Definitely a good article. It might even have helped make the author's point to add that many Albion fans couldn't accept Robson's move even when it did happen, showing that, back then, 'smaller' clubs could genuinely hope to hold on to their best young players in the face of advances from the big boys.

I would also say that, rightly or wrongly, Robson was not universally welcomed as a returning hero when he came back to Albion as manager in 2004. The fact that he was replacing a largely popular figure in Gary Megson (don't laugh Bolton fans), and his own unconvincing managerial record thus far, undoubtedly played a part in that but so too did his, to many, unsatisfactory departure all those years before.

Still very much agree with your central point, however.

Related articles

Player trafficking: the dirty secret of football's global transfer business
The issue remains a huge problem for professional football yet goes largely ignored by those with the power to stop it happening 4 May ~ The...
Football’s Secret Trade: How the player transfer market was infiltrated
by Alex Duff and Tariq Panja Bloomberg, £20Reviewed by Jonathan O’BrienFrom WSC 364, June 2017Buy the book “A player’s...