THE HALF DECENT FOOTBALL MAGAZINE

3 April ~ Brentford's visit to Wembley for the Johnstone's Paint Trophy final with Carlisle today is a chance to meet some of the season's raised expectations generated by the increased playing budget provided by owner Matthew Benham. The Carling Cup run which saw off Hull and Everton and took eventual winners Birmingham to a penalty shoot-out plus excellent away wins at Southampton and Charlton (for the first time in 51 and 85 years respectively) was interspersed with some truly dire performances. Most notably there was the abject 5-1 mauling at Dagenham which proved to be a defeat too far for manager Andy Scott.

His (for now) temporary replacement, Nicky Forster, has lifted the shackles from players trapped in Scott's rigid functional style and the likes of Sam Saunders and Toumani Diagouraga are beginning to show the ability we all suspected they possessed. Some excellent results and more attractive football have almost certainly come too late for a play-off push but have left fans wondering what might have been.

Brentford and Carlisle are two evenly matched sides separated in the league only by goal difference until last Tuesday and the result is probably too close to call. With a team in good form and eight loanees to choose from, Forster will find it tough to choose his starting 11. Unfortunately, Richard Lee, whose penalty saving heroics kept Brentford alive in both the Carling Cup and Johnstone's Paint Trophy, and Charlie MacDonald are both injured. But Gary Alexander seems to like playing at Wembley and he'll probably be joined up front by the splendidly-named and lightning-fast Jeffrey Schlupp, on loan from Leicester via Germany Under-19s. He's already announced his intentions by scoring three times in two starts, including the goals that beat Carlisle in last Friday's league rehearsal.

Whatever the shortcomings of the Johnstone's Paint Trophy as a competition, it certainly captures the imagination of both players and fans from the semi-final stage onwards. Brentford have sold nearly 25,000 tickets – five times the average home attendance. We're all well aware that outside the two clubs involved, nobody really remembers past winners but it would do Brentford a lot of good to break their big-match hoodoo. This includes Football League Trophy defeats in 1985 and 2001, not to mention play-off final defeats in 1997 and 2002. Perhaps a more lasting legacy, though, would be if some of those extra 20,000 were inspired to attend Griffin Park rather more regularly in the future. Chris Dean

Comments (5)
Comment by Alive With Tony 2011-04-03 11:46:11

One of the highlights of my football supporting life was watching my home team, Wigan Athletic, defeat Brentford at Wembley in 1985 ... and then enjoying the warmth with which we were received at the club pre-match at Griffin Park in the following season ... I still possess a very small metallic Bees badge purchased that day ...

I wish you luck today in hopefully celebrating your own win and this leading to greater things in the near future ...

Comment by cantagalo 2011-04-03 19:40:31

Thanks for that, Tony. I was there too but little did I realise that it would be the first of so many big match disappointments, including, of course, today.

Comment by madmickyf 2011-04-05 04:52:26

"With a team in good form and eight loanees to choose from". Are clubs seriously allowed to eight players on loan these days? If so that is a ridiculous amount, surely that is an unfair advantage over teams that develop and sign and develop their own players rather than just loan them from bigger clubs?

Comment by cantagalo 2011-04-05 07:14:00

I believe that only five loanees are allowed in the matchday squad. On Sunday, Brentford started with three, one of whom was withdrawn at half-time. Another came on as a late sub.

Unfair? Well, most League 1 and 2 clubs make extensive use of the loan system and richer clubs welcome the chance to give some competitive experience to young players from their bloated squads.

Comment by madmickyf 2011-04-06 04:53:25

Maybe its time to limit EPL squad sizes (especially at Youth level) to stop them hoovering up all the best talent for themselves. Then there would be more players available for those League 1 and 2 clubs to sign and develop themselves.

Related articles

What Griffin Park lacks in glamour it makes up for with simple joy
Fans don't got to Brentford's stadium for prestige, they go for the local character and, recently, the brilliant entertainment 23 July ~ I...
Turf Wars: A history of London football by Steve Tongue
Pitch Publishing, £9.99Reviewed by Si HawkinsFrom WSC 360, February 2017Buy this book History may teach us the mistakes of the past, but...
Brentford need to regroup after shambolic start to season
New head coach Lee Carsley hasn’t yet had an impact on poor performances 16 October ~ When Brentford supporters looked at the fixture list at the...