THE HALF DECENT FOOTBALL MAGAZINE

12 January ~ It's very difficult to argue against the inclusion of Barcelona's supremely talented trio of Lionel Messi, Andrés Iniesta and Xavi on the FIFA Ballon D'Or shortlist. But the one man who may have a case for complaint is Wesley Sneijder, of Internazionale and Holland.

Granted, Barcelona are the greatest club team in the world currently. Messi, announced as the winner of the award that has merged the FIFA World Player of the Year and the Ballon D'Or earlier in the week, is befitting of such an honour, and Iniesta and Xavi deserve recognition too. There is an unwritten rule in FIFA that their top personal accolade in a World Cup year should be awarded to whoever influenced the international competition the most. Fabio Cannavaro in 2006, Ronaldo in 2002, Zinedine Zidane in 1998 and Romário in 1994 all seem to adhere to this theory. So quite why Messi won this year's award after his lacklustre showing in South Africa is anyone's guess.

Sneijder, by contrast, led the unfancied Dutch side to the World Cup final, scoring five goals along the way – making him the competition's joint top scorer. It should be noted that two of Sneijder's goals (or just one for the pessimists out there) were scored in the quarter-final upset over Brazil, one of the few highlights of a dreary World Cup. The 26-year-old also picked up four man-of-the-match awards in eight games. Meanwhile, Messi couldn't get a kick as Germany humiliated Argentina.

Now of course, Iniesta and Xavi won the tournament with Spain so no ill-feeling could be  construed if they won the Ballon D'Or as a result. Yet they came second and third respectively, with Messi named the winner, presumably on Barcelona's form over the past year? Yet Sneijder's Inter, while nowhere near as glamorous, won the Champions League on top of the Italian league and cup. Their victory may have been built upon solid foundations rather than the Barcelona model of beauty, but regardless they came away from the Camp Nou with a semi-final victory in which Messi was scarcely involved.

Sneijder would have been the first player in history to win a club treble and a World Cup in the same season had his Dutch team-mates crossed the final hurdle. Although this wasn't deemed good enough, he should know that whatever name Sepp Blatter pulls out of an envelope isn't necessarily the most deserving winner. James Dielhenn

Comments (3)
Comment by Incandenza 2011-01-12 14:17:25

If this vote had simply been using the old Ballon d'Or system (only journalists voting), and not the combined FIFA award with their voters, [url=http://football-italia.net/jan11s.html]Sneijder would have won[/url] (with Iniesta in second place, Xavi in third, and Messi in fourth).

Comment by Incandenza 2011-01-12 14:18:00

Sorry, didn't know the UBB code didn't work here. That should read, "Sneijder would have won" where the link is.

Comment by CoffeeBreath 2011-01-13 17:20:05

I'm not much of a Messi fan, but I think he deserved it more than Xavi or Iniesta... especially more than Iniesta. Giving the award to Iniesta would have been like Wedge taking all the glory at the end of Star Wars, sure he was the one that shot the missile that blew up the Death Star but Luke did all the work --- Iniesta scored a World Cup final goal, but what about Puyol's header against Germany or all the goals scored by Villa? Messi at Barcelona was phenomenal, Iniesta is more of a support striker, but not the be-all of Barcelona --- what makes Barcelona run is Xavi & Messi, and some might say really Messi, you take Messi out of Barcelona, I don't think they would be as dominant as they are today. As for Sneijder, great player but I knew Holland's dirty play down the stretch was going to jeapordize his chances of winning the award. For this he can blame his buddies, De Jong & Van Bommel.

Related articles

Hopes for 2018 ~ part one
Embed from Getty Images // A failed World Cup, underdogs having their day and free drinks during VAR decisions – WSC contributors on what...
The best and worst moments of 2017 ~ part two
Embed from Getty Images // From Lincoln’s triumphant season to Huddersfield’s heart-warming promotion, via Chelsea’s return to...
The Fall Of The House Of FIFA by David Conn
Yellow Jersey Press, £16.99Reviewed by Jon Driscoll From WSC 367, September 2017Buy the book I doubt you would enjoy reading David Conn&...