THE HALF DECENT FOOTBALL MAGAZINE

15 November ~ In Italy, il modello inglese is one of those phrases that is generally bandied around whenever an ambitious presidente announces plans for a new, out-of-town stadium, to be populated by smiling passive consumers with official club shop bags tucked dutifully under their reserved seats. Now, however, a more palatable English model is establishing itself in the Italian game. Earlier this summer, fans of Serie D side Unione Venezia announced the formation of Venezia United, taking their lead from the various trusts that have been a part of the British footballing landscape during the last decade and enlisting the help of the European arm of UK organisation Supporters Direct.

Venezia United are not the first Italian club to launch such a scheme (both Ancona, in Serie B last year but demoted down to D after bankruptcy, and Cavese have trusts set up with Supporters Direct’s involvement), but they are the most high profile, bringing national press focus on the idea of clubs run with the direct involvement of fans.

Venezia were relegated from Serie A in 2002. With their Pierluigi Penzo stadium sitting out on the Sant’Elena island and players such as Pippo Maniero and Alvaro Recoba appearing in their distinctive black, orange and green shirts, the lagunari were a favourite with neutrals, a unique club for a unique city. When president Maurizio Zamparini sold up and headed south for Palermo (taking a fair chunk of the playing staff with him), Venezia hit a downward spiral of debt and disaster from which they never recovered.

Relegation to Serie B was quickly followed by financial problems (sadly an all-too-common curse; Zamparini had originally saved the club from bankruptcy when he bought them back in 1987). Their involvement in the 2005 match-fixing scandal with Genoa then saw them demoted down to Serie C2. Finally, last year, with financial irregularities again playing their part, they were relegated to Serie D and amateur football. Having dropped off the calcio radar, a fan group announced in June of this year that it had formed a supporters’ trust, aiming to establish a key role in securing the future of the club and, in the words of its new manfiesto, to cultivate a “sense of belonging, attachment and attention” to the team among the Venetian community.

Venezia United hope to raise €300,000 (£254,000) by next summer, allowing them to buy up ten per cent of the club (with the full support of president Enrico Rigoni), and currently boast 1,000 members who have so far pitched in some €25,000 (fans can join up for a fee of €10 but are encouraged to make larger donations). A website runs video highlights and interviews with players and staff, supplies pdfs of match programmes and provides live commentary on the Radio Venezia United channel. There’s a great feeling of inclusion, of bringing fans together and reminding the outside world that Unione Venezia are still very much alive. With the backing of the mayor and local council, the ultimate ambition is to emulate the successes of AFC Wimbledon and FC United of Manchester and to set up Italy’s first community club, one that can then go on truly to represent a city of Venice’s size and international profile.

There’s been plenty of talk of new dawns in Italian football, of clubs buying up their stadiums, of more equitable television deals, of improved security. Looking at supporters as a possible solution to calcio’s ills, as opposed to being one of its biggest problems, has never really been part of the equation before. Venezia United are working hard to allow fans a crucial say in the running of their often troubled club. At the same time, they’re setting a template for changing the Italian game at a grassroots level and, just possibly, further up the league structure too. Matthew Barker

Comments (6)
Comment by Coral 2010-11-15 14:21:37

Hopefully they won't go on to claim they invented Non-League football as FC United do.

This though is admirable from Venezia fans and have read a bit about them in WSC over the last year or so, a favourite team of mine having been to the ground and getting a boat there to do so. Best of luck to them.

Comment by salfordia 2010-11-15 18:40:06

I don't remember FC United claiming to have invented non-league football. Do you have a link to that particular press release, perchance?

Comment by Coral 2010-11-17 10:16:44

Ah defeated by the link request. I don't have a link to Gordon Brown claiming responsibility for the current financial issues within Britain, must not be true.

Comment by El_Guapo 2010-11-17 12:57:39

Yes, FC United is an odd one. Totally different to AFC Wimbledon (if these Man United drop outs wanted to support a more community based team, why not go and swell the numbers at Bury, for instance?). AFC Wimbledon was formed out of true necessity (ie their club had physically been stolen from them).

How come no mention of the mighty Exeter City? IMO opinion it was an even more impressive achievement by our Supporters Trust to clean up the mess we were left with in 2003 (rather than starting from nothing with a 'clean slate') and have arguably been the most successful of the 3 trust owned clubs.

Good luck to Venezia United - I will be following their progress with great interest.

Comment by salfordia 2010-11-29 15:08:36

Of course Coral, expecting you to back up your claims with evidence is clearly ridiculous.

FC United are a club with a strong ethos and political stance. It's not just about what the owners are doing to Manchester United, it's about us being disaffected with the way of modern football. You can criticise us all you want, but we really don't give a damn - we're everything that's right about football these days.

Comment by drew_whitworth 2010-12-02 19:59:21

@salfordia; I realise it's easy to get into a 'they/we are more "real" than you are' debate when discussing grass-roots sport but it is not completely fair to claim that FCUM are "everything that's right" about football. As another comment thread indicates, FCUM have an innate advantage over other non-league clubs both in their region and nationally because by reporting and promoting them, newspapers will inevitably pull in MUFC fans who have a second-hand interest in them, in a way they don't for Droylsden (the example used in the other story). It also remains to be seen what will happen to FCUM's support, in fact their whole ethos, if the Glazers were to sell up to interests that the fans considered acceptable. This puts them in a very different situation from AFC Wimbledon and Venezia.

Don't get me wrong, I have a lot of time for FCUM - and as a Brighton fan I have to say you thoroughly deserved your result at Withdean both on the pitch and off it [& may well beat us in the replay due to Poyet's dismissive and disappointing attitude to the competition]; but your final comment is an overstatement.

Related articles

Hope for 2018 ~ part two
Embed from Getty Images // No more gambling ads, reform in Spain and Italy, and England playing in the Football League – WSC contributors&...
The best and worst moments of 2017 ~ part two
Embed from Getty Images // From Lincoln’s triumphant season to Huddersfield’s heart-warming promotion, via Chelsea’s return to...
Italian football must do more than read Anne Frank to tackle fascism problem
Embed from Getty Images // The racism and anti-semitism highlighted by Lazio’s fans and owner runs deeper than one club in Italy and all...