WSC Logo

rss

Sign up for the WSC Weekly Howl

A small portion of despair and enlightenment delivered to your inbox every Friday

 

First name
Surname
Email

newissue medrec 333

gplus50

footballartbanner1



Welcome, Guest
Straight Outta Compton IN/ENG Test series
(1 viewing) (1) Guest

TOPIC: Straight Outta Compton IN/ENG Test series

posted 13-12-2012 07:16
England have brought in Bresnan for the injured Finn and maybe surprisingly, Root for Patel.

Only one seamer on each side.

Cook fails again...
  • hobbes
  • A bastion of rightness in a wrong world
  • Posts: 11435
posted 13-12-2012 11:48
The Guardian's OBO description of Cook's wicket:-

WICKET! England 16-2 (Cook LBW b Sharma 1) A huge moment in the match and the series. Alastair Cook has gone for 1 from 28 balls, LBW to Ishant Sharma. It looks a terrible decision from Kumar Dharmasena. Sharma jagged one back to Cook from over the wicket, but it didn't do nearly enough off the seam and would surely have missed off stump. Sharma beseeched Dharmasena to raise the finger, and after a few seconds' thought he did just that. I'm sure that would have been overturned with DRS. In fact it him him outside the line and was going further away from the stumps. That's a stinker.
posted 13-12-2012 11:49
England's slowest-scoring day in years (199/5). Root looks pretty settled, 300+ should be the target here.

PS to Hobbes- aye, the ump had an off-day. Bad karma for Dharma.
Last Edit: 13-12-2012 11:50:34 by Duncan Gardner.
posted 14-12-2012 11:05
England 330 all out.
India 87-4 at stumps.

That's 417 runs in two days and 186.5 overs. That's slow...
posted 14-12-2012 15:27
If Root or Compton never play for England again, does this mean that we'll never see a photograph of them in England kit?
posted 14-12-2012 16:05
Or of them being presented with their test caps?

I wonder if the BCCI ban extends to use of photographs after the tour is over. If so, we may in "historical re-creation" territory.

I haven't seen the clip yet, but the press descriptions of Tendulkar's dismissal are depressing. It's very sad to see a great batsman reduced to a shadow of his former self. No one likes to remember Wille Mays with the Mets.
posted 14-12-2012 16:22
ursus arctos wrote:


I haven't seen the clip yet, but the press descriptions of Tendulkar's dismissal are depressing. It's very sad to see a great batsman reduced to a shadow of his former self. No one likes to remember Wille Mays with the Mets.

Ursus, it was a very good ball that would have troubled batsmen in much better form than Tendulkar. It cut from off to middle stump and kept a little low, so there was no shame in him getting out to it.

Anderson is as good an English seam bowler as I've seen and can conjure up slight movement on even the most unhelpful pitches.

I agree with you about Tendulkar though. It's not the way anyone wanted to see him end his career.
Last Edit: 14-12-2012 16:23:08 by meregreen.
posted 14-12-2012 20:12
Gangster Octopus wrote:
If Root or Compton never play for England again, does this mean that we'll never see a photograph of them in England kit?


Surely it'll be on their twitter accounts or similar?
posted 14-12-2012 23:18
meregreen wrote:
Anderson is as good an English seam bowler as I've seen and can conjure up slight movement on even the most unhelpful pitches.


I was listening to TMS near the end of the days play, Aggers and Boycott commentating whilst Anderson bowled. They were comparing him to past players, and the names they came up with were Malcolm Marshall and Richard Hadlee. Now Aggers can be a bit of a fanboy, but for Boycott to be praising someone from the modern game to that extent is unusual.
posted 14-12-2012 23:27
Gangster Octopus wrote:
England 330 all out.
India 87-4 at stumps.

That's 417 runs in two days and 186.5 overs. That's slow...


Scoring is so slow that England were not concerned about exceeding the minimum overs required. That is hugely uncommon these days. Mostly whichever team is bowling is intent on holding the batting sides momentum back, with the concern being that a single high scoring session could swing a match.
posted 14-12-2012 23:41
Janik wrote:
I was listening to TMS near the end of the days play, Aggers and Boycott commentating whilst Anderson bowled. They were comparing him to past players, and the names they came up with were Malcolm Marshall and Richard Hadlee. Now Aggers can be a bit of a fanboy, but for Boycott to be praising someone from the modern game to that extent is unusual


Boycott overdoes nostalgia for his older 1960s team-mates (Truman, Close, Illingworth), but his hero is Verity who died when Geoffrey was still a toddler.
  • Etienne
  • Life sorted but now lacking time for OTF
  • Posts: 8510
posted 15-12-2012 08:05
Impressive attritional batting from Kohli and Dhoni. Difficult to see it leading to a win at the moment, unless they replace the roller with a plough between innings, but it's the sort of partnership that India needed to show that they can guts it out.
posted 16-12-2012 01:51
Gangster Octopus wrote:
If Root or Compton never play for England again, does this mean that we'll never see a photograph of them in England kit?

Phil Brown (who I think is PA's England cricket guy) was there when I was in Ahmedabad, and there were a couple of others about. So photos exist.

In fact - despite them going on about having no cameras in the ground when coming in, there was a guy sat behind us who brought in an SLR with a massive telephoto lens. Just kept it at the bottom of his bag when entering and wrapped the lens in a plastic bag so it wasn't so visible. He surely must have been spotted by at least one Indian policeman, but if he was they didn't bother him.
  • ad hoc
  • Camisa 10 da Gávea bit.ly/1k0aYAI
  • Posts: 9914
posted 16-12-2012 06:59
I see E10's up for the OBO in the final session today. Good luck with that. It sounds...well like real old school attritional test cricket.

As I write Cook has just got his second run after something like 55 balls.
posted 16-12-2012 12:29
I'm happy with attritional test cricket - it's what we were brought up on. I've been watching a fair bit as well.

What I don't get is the complete absence of urgency fron the Indian team. They are 2-1 down with only one test left and at no time have they ever grasped that a turgid draw will secure a series defeat. Why have they never pushed to get quick runs, employ more attacking fields - get England into more vulnerable positions? It has felt throughout the past four days that they were just as keen as England for this test to end as a draw. It puzzles me.
posted 16-12-2012 16:32
I guess it feels like an improvement on the two previous games, in which they were fairly abject. Push too hard to score quickly and they get castigated for not playing shots appropirate to the pitch and match situtation. Likewise with setting agressive fields, which could force wickets but might also allow the batsmen to score much quicker and get away from you.
posted 16-12-2012 16:33
Cook fired off by Dharmasena for the 2nd time in the game, and Kohli seems to have upped his levels of gobshitery since finally making a score in the series.

It was laughable watching Ishant Sharma giving Jonny Trott verbals. It must be like being sledged by Alesha Dixon with a beard.
  • nmrfox
  • This is why events unnerve me
  • Posts: 924
posted 16-12-2012 18:26
Dhoni's decision to bat on for an hour to score 29 runs was utterly baffling, especially as runs were turned down by Ashwin. The fact that they need to win this Test seems to have passed him by. Surely the best decision would have been to declare overnight and get as long as poss to bowl England out.

What Jimmy says is right - if England can bat through the first hour tomorrow and the new ball is due in this time - then they should be okay to get the draw. What would be fun if England get a lead of around 300 with around half the day to go - would it be worth while declaring to go for a 3-1 win (knowing that India would have a go) or carry on batting the day out. I think Cook will opt for the latter option should that scenario prevail.
posted 16-12-2012 21:54
Can't see Cook declaring under any circumstances. Imagine the criticism he'd get if they lost.
posted 17-12-2012 17:04
Well done England. Good to see some new faces in the top six and a return to form for Monty. Quicks losing form and fitness is a problem though.

Tendulkar should retire and Dhoni hand over the test captaincy.
Time to create page: 0.23 seconds

 

© When Saturday Comes Limited 2014 | Contact | Privacy & cookies | Sitemap | Managed hosting by Latitude