WSC Logo

rss

Sign up for the WSC Weekly Howl

A small portion of despair and enlightenment delivered to your inbox every Friday

 

First name
Surname
Email

newissue medrec 316

gplus50

wsc writers comp

chairman 170x140



Welcome, Guest
Completely Missed Point of Lyrics Thread
(1 viewing) (1) Guest
  • Page:
  • 1
  • 2

TOPIC: Completely Missed Point of Lyrics Thread

posted 17-08-2012 12:49
A Bananarama fan pointed out to me that 'Robert de Niro's Waiting' is actually a song about a girl using a Robert de Niro fantasy to get away from thoughts of date rape, which was quite a surprise.


Funnily enough I heard about that theory quite recently as well. Looking at the lyrics I suppose it would fit. It certainly puts the jaunty little 80's pop number in a completely different light.

And everyone must know by now that Prince's (and Sinead O'Connor's) lost love weep fest "Nothing Compares 2 U" is in fact about giving up cigarettes.
posted 17-08-2012 13:07
It took me many years to realise that the protagonist of "Green Green Grass of Home" was about to be executed. Not helped by mishearing "Sad old Padre" as "Sad old Portrait"

I genuinely thought he was singing "There stands a guard and a sad old portrait" meaning a fireplace with a picture hanging over it.


And it took 30 odd years for the penny to drop that O C Smith's "Son of Hickery Holler's Tramp" was about a woman turning to prostitution to feed her children.
posted 17-08-2012 13:38
Geoffrey de Ste. Croix wrote:


But my favourite remains the US Army's use of Neil Young's "Rockin' in the Free World" in psychological loud music campaigns.

From Afghanistan to Panama to Iraq via other hotspots, they've blasted it out at their enemies at ear-splitting levels wholly unaware that the song is actually a trenchant critique of the United States social problems as a direct result of the Reagan and Bush I administrations-of which vainglorious militarism was an essential component.


Doubly silly as it's rather a good tune.
  • ad hoc
  • Erdely Tripper
  • Posts: 7650
posted 17-08-2012 19:51
  • AB2
  • Churchill was a shopping bag
  • Posts: 6044
posted 17-08-2012 22:14
Mat wrote:
Hmm, that's the thing though Geoff. Maybe they are aware of it, but dismiss the content on the grounds that the form itself is seen as part and parcel of American cultural dominance and imperialism.

It's like David Cameron and his espoused love of 'The Eton Rifles'. He knows full well the lyric of the song despises the constituency that he represents, but he appropriates the song on the basis that pop music in terms of the UK also represents the last bit of cultural power the nation has left. It's very calculated, the buggers know what they're doing though.


I had assumed Cameron was singing the track's praises in an (equally calculated) "look, I can laugh at myself and my own kind, I'm not a bad bloke" kind of way.
  • Wyatt Earp
  • This whole imbroglio is epiphenomenal
  • Posts: 22981
posted 17-08-2012 23:14
I understand (via my Oxbridge connections, like) that it was actually hugely popular at Eton. (Which kind of makes sense, given the way adolescent guys tend to kick a bit against institutions and authority and that.)
posted 17-08-2012 23:39
The oldest one I know of is the Gershwin's "Strike Up the Band" which was written as a satirical song about jumping on the bandwagon for going to war, and apparently Irving Berlin (I think, not sure, maybe this is apocryphal) told them it was going to be re-purposed as a pro-war song before the song was 10 years old. You son of a gun, of a gun...
posted 23-08-2012 13:17
I could never understand:

"Don't get so excited, when I come home a little late at night"

as my sister and I were always dead excited on a Friday night as our dad was allowed home from work early - what could possibly be exciting about someone coming home late?
  • Mat
  • A Knife, A Fork, A Bottle And A Cork
  • Posts: 1663
posted 23-08-2012 15:02
Wyatt Earp wrote:
I understand (via my Oxbridge connections, like) that it was actually hugely popular at Eton. (Which kind of makes sense, given the way adolescent guys tend to kick a bit against institutions and authority and that.)


Yeah, but tempered I would imagine, with that innate knowledge that they are born to rule if you get me.
  • Wyatt Earp
  • This whole imbroglio is epiphenomenal
  • Posts: 22981
posted 24-08-2012 21:09
Mat wrote:

Yeah, but tempered I would imagine, with that innate knowledge that they are born to rule if you get me.


With the odd Eric Blair/Tam Dalyell style exceptions, I think that's probably right, yeah.
posted 25-08-2012 20:14
Smallcaps wrote:
This may not be news to anyone, but I heard that people have U2's One playing at their wedding, even though it's actually about a couple's dissolution.


Same goes for Heart's 'All I Want To Do Is Make Love To You.'
posted 26-08-2012 14:36
That Dandy Warhols song from a few years back. 'Bohemian Like You'. It was a really vicious and angry diatribe against slackerdom, that was used by BT to promote some new call facility they were promoting.

They'd already covered this subject area pretty adequately in 'Not if You Were the Last Junkie On Earth' - which had some great lyrics.

Is it just a rumour that 'Perfect Day' was a tribute to heroin addiction.

Nope, not a rumour. See also: 'There She Goes', 'Golden Brown', etc, etc.

Babybird's 'You're Gorgeous' is another one, of course - but I think that record's been spoken of more on OTF than almost any other in music history...
Last Edit: 26-08-2012 14:38:52 by Jah Womble.
posted 26-08-2012 20:55
In Decline of Western Civilization, Johnny Doe was saying how X stopped playing "Johnny Hit and Run Paulene" because concertgoers were evidently taking it as a pro-date-rapist anthem instead of the anti-rape song that it was.

Same goes for the Stone Temple Pilots "Sex Type Thing," which was an anti-rape song that was taken as a rapist's anthem.
  • MsD
  • Forum Sweetheart and Friend of the Stars
  • Posts: 5150
posted 07-09-2012 11:05
Just seen someone advising people to "have a smoke" and listen to Ian Brown's (brilliant, brilliant) F E A R, because drugs "open the mind". It's a song about recovery.
posted 07-09-2012 15:05
I guess you can include "The Drugs Don't Work" as well, especially with how many people wanted to ban the song...which is about chemotherapy not working on cancer.
posted 07-09-2012 15:13
Pretty much everyone involved with Grandmasters Flash and Melle Mel was 'using' at the time of 'White Lines (Don't Don't Do It)'.

But that's a factual irony rather than a lyrical paradox.
Last Edit: 07-09-2012 15:54:03 by Jah Womble.
  • Page:
  • 1
  • 2
Time to create page: 0.28 seconds

 

© When Saturday Comes Limited 2013 | Contact | Privacy & cookies | Sitemap | Managed hosting by Latitude