Diable Rouge wrote:
It's 90% mindless aggro, but 10% is arguably a loyalist sense of alienation that neither Unionist party is defending working-class Protestant communities, while their republican counterparts are reaping the SF rewards, so the issue just proved a convenient catalyst to express pent-up angst
Maybe. Of course they could vote for local councillors who do try to provide practical help to their communities. Like Greens, Socialists and er, Alliance.
You're right that 'Themmuns get everything' (NI's version of zero-sum game politics) is widely perceived. But there's plenty of social deprivation and the rest in Nationalist areas.
Sean of the Shed wrote:
I might be appearing naive here, but if less significance was attached to the Union Jack by Republicans, then maybe it would undermine the symbolism it currently has with the idiots amongst the Unionists
Again, maybe. The broad problem is that single-issue cock/ flag-waving parties get 85-90% of the vote in every NI election, while the three main British parties either ignore it, or (in Labour's case) actually prevent local activists standing on the party's ticket.
sw2boropetrovsk wrote:
So, is the possibility of Scottish independence a thing in Northern Ireland? Just it makes me think that it's the big undiscussed question in the conversation here, but could mean that the whole current settlement, such as it is, could unravel
Not that big an issue, I think. NI's particular volatility means independence isn't a realistic possibility, while the Republic's politicians and wider public opinion have long made it obvious that their priority is protesting discrimination or intimidation against Nationalists, not reuniting with them. Three of the biggest four Southern parties (FG, FF and Labour) have never stood in any NI election.
PS a brief explanation of the
Gulliver's Travels reference. Swift lived in Belfast while employed as a clergyman nearby. His cottage stood where Lilliput Street (beside B126/ Limestone Road junction on detailed map below). Local Crusaders FC narrowly avoided becoming the Lilliputians when founded in 1898. The name is now shared by an industrial laundry firm.