Lucia Lanigan wrote:
I loved Alan Moore's From Hell when I read it a few years ago. It's only now I realise that the "ten years of research" he put into it must have involved reading Sinclair's White Chapell... and Lud Heat over and over, because From Hell is bascially a mash-up of the two - almost everything is a direct lift! But no one will tell you this because they don't want to say anything bad about Alan Moore, cause he's good, and nice.
I am curious to read
White Chappell. I also agree that
From Hell was very well done. However, both of them would surely give major credit of the Duke of Clarence/William Gull storyline to Stephen Knight's
Jack the Ripper: The Final Solution. It was the first Ripper book I'd read and it was a fascinating read...and crushing to find that it was all an elaborate work of fiction.
No matter. Patricia Cornwall pushes it farther and names a solo Walter Sickert as the unquestionably the Ripper in her book
Portrait of a Killer: Jack the Ripper - Case Closed a few years ago. Nowhere is Stephen Knight mentioned in the book.