El Tel wrote:
Leon Tricker wrote:
Pompey fan here… Basically, I’m comfortable with the deduction and sanctions the League are imposing. PFC deserves the points deduction.
Fair enough, but I must admit I struggle to understand this point of view.
The goal of the Football authorities should be to provide the sort of
PRO-ACTIVE oversight needed to prevent clubs being driven into administration and/or being run by crooks. The FA and FL have failed miserably to do either of those things hence you have clubs in the predicament that you find yourselves in.
Point penalties are entirely
RE-ACTIVE,do nothing to address the root causes of financial mismanagement and as ADC has already noted upthread are not an effective deterrent.
In any case the people largely responsible for this mess are long gone and will care not one jot about another point penalty being imposed on Pompey. Meanwhile the likes of you and your fellow loyal supporters are left to clean up the wreckage, the whole thing stinks.
I don’t disagree with any of what you’ve, other than to say I think points penalties should run alongside sanctions for owners / crooks.
I think there is an argument that the actions of dodgy owners can lead to success on the pitch, and I think this needs to be reflected somehow. So, yeah, punish the owners – but if sporting advantage has been gained then this needs to be countered in some way. A points deduction seems as appropriate a gesture as any other.
I also think that points deductions, because they hit the people left behind, have led to Pompey fans taking a greater level of interest in what the owners are doing, which I would say is a positive development.
Jongudmund wrote:
El Tel wrote:
RE-ACTIVE,[/b]do nothing to address the root causes of financial mismanagement and as ADC has already noted upthread are not an effective deterrent.
In any case the people largely responsible for this mess are long gone and will care not one jot about another point penalty being imposed on Pompey. Meanwhile the likes of you and your fellow loyal supporters are left to clean up the wreckage, the whole thing stinks.
Yep, I agree with this. More should be done to punish the people who caused the problems rather than the clubs. In Portsmouth's case Mr H Redknapp should be investigated as partly culpable, IMHO.
I’d be interested in why you think Redknapp is cupable. A lot of Pompey fans would certainly agree with you.
I’m no great fan of his, but I tend to feel the blame ultimately lies with Gaydamak. Redknapp was no doubt putting a great deal of pressure on the owner to sign players. I suspect Gaydamak believed Redknapp was bigger than the club, and wanted to keep him onside. But it’s Gaydamak’s fault for signing cheques he ultimately couldn’t cover, surely?
Peter Storrie, the old chief exec, has to take his share of the blame for his poor contract negotiations – the salaries, the add-ons, the image rights, the lack of relegation clauses etc.
JM Footzee wrote:
Portsmouth have
gone on a pre-season tour. Seems strange that they can afford to do that, especially as they have no idea whether they'll be able to/want to recruit the trialists they've taken.
It’s something that we’re wondering too. One theory is the trip is being funded by the ‘high worth’ investors working with the supporters trust.