We've not got any Dundee fans on here, have we?
It's been interesting following the managerial story there this week. Most neutrals felt sacking Barry Smith was harsh. Dundee had about a week to get ready for the SPL and so no time to prepare a squad seems to be the narrative being followed. Unfortunately it isn't entirely accurate. They didn't know which league they'd be in officially, that's true, but they signed 13 players in the summer. If those players were signed to win Div 1 then it still doesn't explain why they have performed quite as badly as they have this season. Ross County, who also came up last season, signed only 7 players in the summer and currently sit in 5th place although victory tonight will see them jump to second, a remarkable achievement. The gap between the top of Div 1 and the bottom of the SPL isn't that wide.
Smith is an inexperienced manager, he got the job almost be default when Dundee went into administration a couple of seasons ago. To his credit he kept them up following a 25 point deduction and last season took them to 2nd top of the league. This season has gone badly but from the outside it looks like they could have been more understanding. None of us know what was going on in the background though.
Then late last week the club announced they were appointing John Brown as interim manager until the end of the season. Brown was a popular Dundee player in the 80s but was still a surprise choice. He has a lot of coaching experience but not at first team level. His only senior managerial job prior was an unsuccessful stint at Clyde. To be fair to Brown Clyde are resource starved, and are sitting bottom of Div 3 just now, despite being managed by the experienced Jim Duffy, ironically another Dundee legend.
In recent times Brown has been better known for speaking out quite vocally against Rangers CEO Charles Green. Frankly he came across as slightly unhinged, his ranting lacking both substance and credence. It was an episode that didn't do his credibility any favours.
A number of the Dundee support threatened boycotts and rumours of board unrest followed. These turned out to be untrue for now.
The media, particularly the BBC, were remarkably outspoken regarding his appointment. The Scotsman's Tom English, usually sane and measured, described the appointment, on air, as like Matt Bassett, Billy Dodds was equally scathing.
It later transpired Dodds had himself applied for the position.
The Dundee CEO explained his decision quite well I thought. They couldn't offer someone a longer contract than the end of the season because they don't know what league they'll be in next season, with possible reconstruction further muddying those waters. Brown has a lot of coaching experience, particularly with young players, something they thought important as Dundee currently have no scouts in Scotland, I was surprised to learn. Having played for the club Brown has some affinity with them and has also worked with the Dundee CEO in the past too.
Some see that as jobs-for-pals and perhaps it is, but when explained it wasn't quite as baffling an appointment as it seemed at first. Either way, it would take a miracle, or Hearts going into administration, to save Dundee from finishing bottom now.