WSC Logo



SEARCH  

Advanced search

dig
ROB

Weekly Howl

A mixture of comment, fact and captivating trivia via email

Sign up

Follow WSC

 twitter

NEWSFEEDS

sstore

 

HOME arrow WSC DAILY arrow June 2009 arrow England v Germany: same old story
England v Germany: same old story

Image Monday 29 June ~

"There's no doubt there's an extra little incentive because it's Germany. That's the way they think about us and the way we think about them." So says West Ham midfielder Mark Noble ahead of England's European Under-21 Championship final against Germany tonight. Always keen to promote matches being shown exclusively by Sky Sports, the Sun devote a double page spread to the game which includes the claim that it's "43 trophyless years since the Three Lions lifted the World Cup at Wembley".

But that's not true. England have won the biennial competition twice before, in 1982 and 1984. In the first of those finals, then played over two legs, they beat West Germany. That result is overlooked now because it predates the media obsession with 1966 that began in the build up to Euro 96.

Every year that passes without England winning a trophy, another "year of hurt" is added on to references to the Skinner and Baddiel song that was inescapable during Euro 96. That tournament ended with another English defeat to Germany, the third in a major competition since 1966.

German teams have played in far more semi-finals and finals than the English over the period, which is one reason to doubt Noble's suggestion that tonight's opponents have an equally keen feeling for the rivalry; modern football history suggest that a German team is much more likely to encounter France or Italy in the latter stages of a competition than England.

Another comment by Noble gets to the nub: "We all do history at school. When you put an England shirt on and you play against the Germany you want to win." It's war nostalgia again. For 1966 read 1939-45 – the last time that England (in reality Britain, a distinction that tabloid sportswriters tend not to make) was a global power.

It's understandable that the Second World War might have coloured attitudes towards an England v (West) Germany match in 1966, just over 20 years after hostilities ended; less so another 43 years on, especially given that for at least part of the intervening period it had seemed to matter less.

England have defeated Germany twice in competitive matches within the last decade but that has no discernible effect on the perceived rivalry which gets ramped up again in the media before the next encounter. The burden of 1966 will never be shed until England teams create some new national sporting myths by winning things, or at least getting past quarter-finals, on a regular basis. In the meantime stand by for a barrage of war metaphors in tomorrow's match reports. Carl Hawkins

Share this article:
Delicious
Furl it!
Spurl
NewsVine
Reddit
YahooMyWeb
Technorati
Mister.Wong
Comments (3)
Comment by sharon 29-06-2009 21:51    [Offensive? Unsuitable?
Report this comment
]

If history is irrelevant then tell the Australians, Argentinians, Scots, Irish, Welsh..

Comment by salamander 30-06-2009 01:34    [Offensive? Unsuitable?
Report this comment
]

After tonight's 4-0 humiliation, I expect to see the same old excuses trotted out.....
''After such a hard and demanding domestic season is there any wonder that the players were too tired to do themselves justice. And of course, extra-time in the Sweden game will have sapped all their strength''. - The Daily Post.
Don't suppose that any of the German players had to endure a long season, though.
Must be time to reduce the Premiership to perhaps just a dozen clubs, or is that too many?

Comment by G.Man wants a hyphen 30-06-2009 07:26    [Offensive? Unsuitable?
Report this comment
]

It's almost cute how some Engländer are so keen to believe that the big rivalry is reciprocated by Germany. Of course, as you rightly note, it isn't. England fans are mistaken if they think they are the Liverpool to Germany's Man Utd. There is respect for England from the German side, and a desire to beat England. But the real rivalry exists between Germany and the Netherlands.

Comment
You must be logged in to comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 

Today's most read WSC articles

The first time Going to a live match   

Josh Widdicombe   

WSC 270 Aug 09

Paul Brooker The new Giggs   

Adam Powley   

WSC 182 Apr 02

Another fine mess England try to find a new coach   

WSC   

WSC 232 Jun 06

No love, no joy Tim Lovejoy’s rubbish autobiography   

Taylor Parkes   

WSC 250 Dec 07

Pools unto themselves History of the Pools Panel   

Al Needham   

WSC 193 Mar 03

Leyton Orient's North Terrace A tribute   

Tom Davies   

WSC 194 Apr 03

WSC digital edition & apps    

   

 

Death of a salesman Les Sealey tribute   

John Earls   

WSC 176 Oct 01

Keith O'Neill World is his lobster   

Dave Hannigan   

WSC 207 May 04

Exit clause England's World Cup 2006   

WSC   

WSC 234 Aug 06