WSC Logo



SEARCH  

Advanced search

dig
ROB

Weekly Howl

A mixture of comment, fact and captivating trivia via email

Sign up

Follow WSC

 twitter

NEWSFEEDS

sstore

 

HOME arrow WSC DAILY arrow June 2009 arrow A tale of two takeovers
A tale of two takeovers

Image Tuesday 9 June ~

Yesterday Newcastle revealed a new and desperate method of attracting prospective suitors, people who will, it is hoped, end Mike Ashley’s disastrous tenure as owner. Yet the hasty takeover of West Ham, by the creditors of Bjorgolfur Gudmundsson, indicates how there are currently few around that are willing to invest. Reactions to the move to place a For Sale sign on Newcastle's website were predictably derisive. ”eBay the lads”, said the Sun. ”Joke.co.uk”, in the Mirror. Sunderland fans did not limp in making their offers, which ranged from confectionery to £10.

It is unclear how the ill-advised ad, akin to those that promote the replica shirts or trainers of Ashley's Sports Direct stores, will attract anything more serious than these spoofs. Investors possessing the £100 million to match the asking price are unlikely to conduct their football club shopping on the web. They more often prefer to be courted by middlemen, such as the ubiquitous Keith Harris of Seymour Pierce. Harris may now wonder what role his is (assuming that he wasn't directly responsible for the advert).

Two weeks into the close season, Newcastle are directionless. No pre-season arrangements have been made, deliberation continues over the suitability of Alan Shearer as manager and the future of an expensive playing squad is uncertain, though Aston Villa and Fulham are chasing Michael Owen. Meanwhile, over £100m is owed to Ashley. Some may believe the club represents a wise investment at a cut price. But the loss of Premier League status means their debts will grow each year, during which time promotion for a reconfigured side will be difficult. Even were they were an attraction, few globally have the funds to buy a football club anyway. Though the Daily Telegraph do report that a local consortium, involving Freddie Shepherd, is interested.

West Ham will be cited as a sign of hope for clubs waiting to be taken over. Gianfranco Zola has been promised funds for new players and things at the club appear well. However the deal, which saw ownership shift from Bjorgolfur Gudmundsson to CB Holdings, was more forced than planned. CB (Claret and Blue) is the investment vehicle of, among others, Straumur-Burdaras Investment Bank, Iceland. They are owed £80m by Gudmundsson and took control of the Hammers to protect their position. They intend to sell in a few years when economic conditions improve.

Straumer's involvement arose only due to Gudmundsson's plight, not from the desire to buy into the Premier League. It is only the Middle Eastern investors, such the consortium that are looking to purchase Portsmouth or the Abu Dhabi-based Sheikh Mansour Bin Zayed at Manchester City, that bring the genuine wealth that Newcastle and others – the list is lengthy – hope for most. How many of these contacted the club, via This email address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it , is questionable. Tom Whitworth

Share this article:
Delicious
Furl it!
Spurl
NewsVine
Reddit
YahooMyWeb
Technorati
Mister.Wong
Comments (4)
Comment by The Exploding Vole 09-06-2009 15:22    [Offensive? Unsuitable?
Report this comment
]

"Even were they were an attraction, few globally have the funds to buy a football club anyway"?

Comment by onedeadbudgie 09-06-2009 20:09    [Offensive? Unsuitable?
Report this comment
]

In these recessionary times NUFC and Setanta do at least provide some entertainment. As well as the EPL the press are also slow to catch on. On Radio 5 tonight the assembled hacks expressed surprise and disgust that Ashley might no longer care about NUFC and just want to get out and cut his losses. Any sensible person would do that now. The new EPL with foreign owners means that clubs are an investment first. One hack made the point that any sensible buyer - assuming such might exist - would want the high wage surplus players shipped out first. Unless that happens you might not arguably know what you are letting yourself in for. The future looks bleak. Ashley's price of £100m might be a bit hopeful.

Comment by CJW1968 09-06-2009 22:14    [Offensive? Unsuitable?
Report this comment
]

If Ashley wants £100m for Newcastle, then surely a fans' consortium can easily be arranged. Just a £2k outlay for each of Newcastle's 50,000 regulars.

Why hasn't anybody suggested this? After all, we keep hearing about how they are the best fans in the world.

At this rate, with no buyer, no manager and clearly no plan for next season - they surely will fall through the Championship next term. The 12-1 odds on this happening looks quite generous right now.

CJW1968

Comment by jackofalltrades 10-06-2009 02:26    [Offensive? Unsuitable?
Report this comment
]

A fans consortium has been suggested many, many times in the past, but it's just not feasible.

Ashley doesn't just want £100 million for the club, CJW - he's also put the £100 million he's spent since taking over the club onto the books as a loan repayable to him by whoever takes over the club - at a rate of half a percent over bank base rate.

There's also another £60 - 70 million still owing for outstanding transfer payments and 'loyalty' bonuses, plus salaries of (after Owen and Viduka leave - we're still paying them till the end of June) £800,000 PER WEEK to find, with some players - eg Colocinni - on big-money contracts taking them up to 2013.

Then you'd have to find money for new players and a decent manager.

The £100 million he wants for the club isn't just hopeful, it's actually another example of Ashley being away with the fairies - he very publicly bought a Premiership club in 2007 for £130 million and now, in the worst financial climate EVER, is trying to sell a Championship club for £100 million....

Freddie Shepherd was monumentally incompetent at running Newcastle - in 1997, Newcastle were in profit, with money in the bank - ten years later, Shepherd was losing £30 million per year and owed £70 million - this is especially staggering when you consider that Newcastles turnover over this period was nearly £900 million!!

With big payments due and nothing left to borrow against, Ashley's money in the short term undoubtedly got Newcastle out of a hole, but now he's broken his toy and wants his money back, he leaves Newcastle in a far worse position than he found it - we now owe (him) £100 million, and with the loss of Premiership status face losses of easily £50 million....that is quite a feat in just a couple of years. And his current dithering surely bodes badly for Newcastles Championship status.

BTW, CJW, Newcastle don't go round promoting themselves as 'the best fans in the world', it's just lazy media cliche. Nevertheless, as you've noticed yourself, Newcastle have 50,000 enthusiastic regulars which isn't bad for a city with a population of 190,000 - THEY are undoubtedly Newcastle's best asset, but the amounts we're talking about to run a club this size is way, way beyond a fans consortium - Ashley's nearly a billionaire, and he can't afford it...

Comment
You must be logged in to comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 

Today's most read WSC articles

Teenage anguish - USA MLS youth development   

Mike Woitalla   

WSC 145 Mar 99

Oldham Athletic Dowie, Wembley, Division Two   

Steve Ragg   

WSC 194 Apr 03

Major success? MLS's first season   

Mike Woitalla   

WSC 118 Dec 96

Amir Karic and Ulrich Le Pen Not worth the money?   

Jonathan Barnes   

WSC 221 Jul 05

The domination game Praising Chelsea   

WSC   

WSC 217 Mar 05

Unpopularity contest West Ham and Terence Brown   

Darron Kirkby   

WSC 223 Sep 05

States of happiness 1999 women's World Cup   

Ethan Zindler   

WSC 151 Sep 99

Firm Favourites: Old Firm Sectarianism in Scotland   

Dianne Millen   

WSC 206 Apr 04

Kenny Achampong Tricky midfielder who disappeared   

Tom Davies   

WSC 179 Jan 02

No love, no joy Tim Lovejoy’s rubbish autobiography   

Taylor Parkes   

WSC 250 Dec 07