HOME
WSC DAILY
WEEKLY HOWL
THE ARCHIVE
BOOK REVIEWS
PEOPLE
MESSAGE BOARD
LINKS
SHOP



Dots

WSC SHOP

Visit our shop
Dots

NEWSFEEDS

Dots
sub_banner

SEARCH WSC  

Advanced search

Inset for Howl
books offers tower
HOME arrow MESSAGE BOARD
Message Board
Welcome, Guest
The Prosecution Of George W Bush For Murder (1 viewing) (1) Guest
Go to bottom Post Reply Favoured: 0
TOPIC: The Prosecution Of George W Bush For Murder
#66188
The Horse
Posts: 997
User Offline Click here to see the profile of this user
Gender: Male Anthony Michael Hall Fig roll Manufacturing Consent, Noam Chomsky/Edward Herman Never try. Suede, Suede Location: London Birthdate: 1978-01-01
posted 16-07-2008 14:27

 
Please note, although no boardcode buttons are shown, they are still useable
 
Logged Logged  
 
#66202
BrunoMaggiore
Posts: 2535
User Offline Click here to see the profile of this user
posted 16-07-2008 14:43

 
At a glance the premise seems daft. If Bush "lied the country into war" there are a whole lot of people who were complicit in that lie, including many members of the other party. Why stop with Bush (or does he). One would be on much firmer ground prosecuting him for specific war crimes, not for the deaths of every soldier who volunteered to follow the orders of the president, with congressional imprimatur.
Please note, although no boardcode buttons are shown, they are still useable
 
Logged Logged  
 
#66333
linus
Posts: 924
User Offline Click here to see the profile of this user
OGCN, les Bleus, the Habs, the Golden Bears Gender: Male John Houseman aniseed biscotti dipped in a cappuccino Budgie 101 Radioaktivität Location: cottageland
posted 16-07-2008 17:52

 
The fact that this comes from a guy was the DA of Los Angeles as opposed to just an activist's blog makes it an interestng read, his legal opinion on the matter has some gravitas.
Please note, although no boardcode buttons are shown, they are still useable
 
Logged Logged  
 
#66919
jason voorhees
Posts: 1063
User Offline Click here to see the profile of this user
NY Cosmos, Racing Club de Avellenda, Colo Colo. Gender: Male Ask the Producers & Money Men Shortbread with Vitamin D Whole Milk is the SHIT Crime & Punishment - Dostoyevsky This shit is a struggle, no doubt. Pink Floyd - The Wall, Location: Nawlins, Leezane Birthdate: 1973-04-07
posted 17-07-2008 12:45

 
Not only that, he was the one who convicted Charles Manson.
Please note, although no boardcode buttons are shown, they are still useable
 
Logged Logged  
 
#67274
Incandenza
Posts: 2753
User Offline Click here to see the profile of this user
UCLA, Galaxy, Lakers Location: The People's Republic of Santa Monica Birthdate: 1979-07-09
posted 17-07-2008 19:17

 
It's on the LA Times bestseller list.
Please note, although no boardcode buttons are shown, they are still useable
 
Logged Logged  
 
#67533
Hofzinser
Posts: 1265
User Offline Click here to see the profile of this user
Gender: Male graduate Bat Out of Hell Location: London Birthdate: 1977-11-03
posted 18-07-2008 09:37

 
Bruno, obviously lots of other people were complicit in the lies that were told - but as commander-in-chief and president of the USA, the buck stops with Bush, no? It seems totally reasonable to hold him responsible for what has happened.

Maybe, as you suggest, we shouldn't stop with Bush, but it certainly seems like the most reasonable place to start.
Please note, although no boardcode buttons are shown, they are still useable
 
Logged Logged  
 
#67788
BrunoMaggiore
Posts: 2535
User Offline Click here to see the profile of this user
posted 18-07-2008 15:27

 
He would have to establish that the war was started illegally and I don't see that happening. Apart from that a government has the legal authority to send its citizens to their deaths.
Please note, although no boardcode buttons are shown, they are still useable
 
Logged Logged  
 
Last Edit: 18-07-2008 15:27 By BrunoMaggiore.
 
#67793
The Horse
Posts: 997
User Offline Click here to see the profile of this user
Gender: Male Anthony Michael Hall Fig roll Manufacturing Consent, Noam Chomsky/Edward Herman Never try. Suede, Suede Location: London Birthdate: 1978-01-01
posted 18-07-2008 15:38

 
Very easy to establish, I would have thought.
Please note, although no boardcode buttons are shown, they are still useable
 
Logged Logged  
 
#67843
BrunoMaggiore
Posts: 2535
User Offline Click here to see the profile of this user
posted 18-07-2008 16:46

 
About as easy as pinning on a very finite set of people, with very expensive lawyers, legal responsibility for actions they could, with said lawyers, very easily associate with many others not belonging to that finite set. Unless we're talking about putting half the U.S. government in the dock.

I would think it would make the very daunting prospect of a war crimes prosecution seem like Disneyland.
Please note, although no boardcode buttons are shown, they are still useable
 
Logged Logged  
 
#67876
The Horse
Posts: 997
User Offline Click here to see the profile of this user
Gender: Male Anthony Michael Hall Fig roll Manufacturing Consent, Noam Chomsky/Edward Herman Never try. Suede, Suede Location: London Birthdate: 1978-01-01
posted 18-07-2008 17:45

 
Hang on, you said "establish that the war was started illegally", not "bring a successful prosecution on those grounds". I assumed you meant establish it in the book, not in court, given that we're talking about a book, not an actual prosecution.

Establishing it in the book would be easy. Page and a half, tops.
Please note, although no boardcode buttons are shown, they are still useable
 
Logged Logged  
 
#67884
BrunoMaggiore
Posts: 2535
User Offline Click here to see the profile of this user
posted 18-07-2008 17:59

 
I was talking about an actual prosecution, which I took to be the point of the book.
Please note, although no boardcode buttons are shown, they are still useable
 
Logged Logged  
 
#67886
The Horse
Posts: 997
User Offline Click here to see the profile of this user
Gender: Male Anthony Michael Hall Fig roll Manufacturing Consent, Noam Chomsky/Edward Herman Never try. Suede, Suede Location: London Birthdate: 1978-01-01
posted 18-07-2008 18:02

 
Er, but the book is a book, not a prosecution. How expensive the other side's lawyers are etc doesn't stop you establishing your case in a book, eg by explaining why the war was illegal, which is dead easy.
Please note, although no boardcode buttons are shown, they are still useable
 
Logged Logged  
 
#67889
wingco
Posts: 612
User Offline Click here to see the profile of this user
Arsenal Gender: Male Marlon Brando, badly, 50 pounds overweight mr agreeable Viennese whirls Plenty novels but life stayed same afterwards One day at a time: Sweet fucking Jesus Innvervisions - Stevie Wonder Location: London Birthdate: 1962-09-13
posted 18-07-2008 18:03

 
I remember reading Bugliosi's book about his Manson prosecution when I was just into my teens.

Part of me rejoices that this book has reached such a big audience despite mainstream squeamishness but I'm inclined to agree with BrunoMaggiore on this one. A prosecution like this wouldn't just be unfeasible on pragmatic grounds - it would be easily swatted away, and anyone calling for it would appear immature to those they were trying to persuade - but Bush, for all his awfulness, is not, I believe, a murderer in any legal sense, nor Blair for that matter. That's not to say that they haven't been instrumental in terrible things - but the responsibility for what they did is collective. You could even extend that "collective" to people like us, whose comfortable lives are maintained by the inherent violence of the states in which we live. Bush and Blair are merely the figureheads of Western rapacity - they rise to prominence and do the things they do because others desire them to.
Please note, although no boardcode buttons are shown, they are still useable
 
Logged Logged  
 
#67894
BrunoMaggiore
Posts: 2535
User Offline Click here to see the profile of this user
posted 18-07-2008 18:05

 
The Horse wrote:
QUOTE:
Er, but the book is a book, not a prosecution. How expensive the other side's lawyers are etc doesn't stop you establishing your case in a book, eg by explaining why the war was illegal, which is dead easy.


Ok, fine, as easy as making the opening argument for the prosecution. Granted. Unless there are two sides arguing their case and an impartial arbiter deciding between them, you haven't really "established" anything.
Please note, although no boardcode buttons are shown, they are still useable
 
Logged Logged  
 
#67898
The Horse
Posts: 997
User Offline Click here to see the profile of this user
Gender: Male Anthony Michael Hall Fig roll Manufacturing Consent, Noam Chomsky/Edward Herman Never try. Suede, Suede Location: London Birthdate: 1978-01-01
posted 18-07-2008 18:08

 
QUOTE:
Unless there are two sides arguing their case and an impartial arbiter deciding between them, you haven't really "established" anything.


Of course you have, as much as you can in a book, which this is. It's no good saying you can't establish things in a book based on the strictures in place in a completely different arena.
Please note, although no boardcode buttons are shown, they are still useable
 
Logged Logged  
 
#67903
BrunoMaggiore
Posts: 2535
User Offline Click here to see the profile of this user
posted 18-07-2008 18:16

 
The Horse wrote:
QUOTE:
Of course you have, as much as you can in a book, which this is. It's no good saying you can't establish things in a book based on the strictures in place in a completely different arena.


It's a book expressly about that completely different arena. For it to be believable as legal theater it would need to make the case for how the defense might well lose such a prosecution. (And I sorta doubt anyone with a passing familiarity with how things would likely play out would be convinced.) Then, for it to really establish anything other than a legal brief, its arguments would need to be applied in that different arena and vindicated. The notion that this was an illegal war has been obvious to everyone inclined to agree with that since 2003, and far from obvious to all those disinclined to agree.
Please note, although no boardcode buttons are shown, they are still useable
 
Logged Logged