Saw this today - thought it was really good, well acted and directed, good story, "twists" that were explanatory rather than tricksy, and with complex moral issues involved. Casey Affleck is really impressive I think, far better than his brother ever was as an actor. I guess the only area in which this could have been improved is with a slightly stronger central female role. Michelle Monaghan's role was more than a little underwritten - I would have preferred something more akin to the 40/50s noir females, where the female lead oftens gets a bit more involved.